Arroyo Grande Oracle: The Arroyo Grande High School class of ’99 will have no commencement this year. Arrangements were being made for the affair and undoubtedly it would have been a grand affair and would certainly have obliterated much of the ill feeling towards the school by our neighbors who dominate the school’s board of control. Certain comments by students and faculty in the Herald caused the ceremony to be declared off by Willis Buck, chairman of the Board of Control. Buck was quoted as saying, “If the students and teachers are not willing to work to build up the school they cannot blame those who are prejudiced for trying to wreck the institution and cause disbandment of the High School district.” Hypocrisy at its grandest, say we.
The Oracle, voice of the Republican party in Arroyo Grande published by Pete Olohan, Saloon keeper, was quick to place the blame.. The Oracle, spinning the coming closing of the school as somehow being the fault of the students and the staff who knew they would be out of a job come June. No one was going to teach at the salaries they were being offered and no one would apply to fill the vacant teaching jobs. The school would be effectively closed. The “Wreckers” put up a smokescreen blaming the blameless and not the miscreants themselves. Why do that? Politics is not a new invention by any means.
The graduates, misses Edith Jatta and Edna Conrad, who would become a teacher in Los Osos, Edith Carpenter and the two young men, the red haired Archer “Arch” Beckett whose father owns most of the western Arroyo Grande district which runs from the sea to the Methodist camp and is an opponent of the High School and Albert Ore who will Study at St Mary’s college to become a pastor. All will receive their diplomas from Principal A. F. Parsons at their homes on Saturday. This could quite possibly be the last class to ever graduate from Arroyo’s high school.
The winsome Miss Edna Conrad, Arroyo Grande High School, class of 1899. Family photo
And so it looked to be, at least for a while.The classes of 1900-1904 were likely to be canceled for lack of funds. Next, the schoolhouse where the high school classes were being held promptly burned down. Less than a month after the board of control apparently ensured the closure of the high school, the building where all classes were taught was destroyed. Now wasn’t that a piece of serendipity. The “Wreckers” were having all the luck.
Arroyo Grande Herald: Oct. 14, 1899. At 3 o’clock this morning the public school building here was completely destroyed by fire, only a very small portion of the furniture being saved.
The Arroyo Grande Union School, 1898. It was the largest building in town and citizens took great pride in it. San Luis Obispo Historical Society.
The loss is estimated at $ 11,00.00 and the building was only insured for $ 7,500.00. The pupils of the school lost all their books, etc. The cause of the fire is said to be a stroke of lighting, but there are some who strongly hint at incendiarism. There is no probability of the fire being caused by a stove in the building as none had been lit since last winter. Principle Parsons stated that all coal-oil lanterns had been extinguished at the end of the day. The schools lightening rod was found in the wreckage, undamaged. Lightning is a very rare occurrence in Arroyo Grande and this raises serious questions. There was no chance to save the building and the walls soon fell in. There is still $ 2,500.00 due on the bond issued to build the school just six years ago.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:Cambria has the wheel craze once more. There are quite a number of new wheels recently purchased and now it boasts over thirty within the city itself, then there are a great many on the outside. It is rumored that the war has caused even some people to have wheels in their head. But we don’t believe that.
On an outing, 1899. National Archives Photo.
The Board of Control was now faced with a problem unanticipated. Luckily, the citizens of the town were quick to rally around the school. A meeting was called for the evening of the 18th at the Good Samaritan’s Hall where over four hundred dollars ($14,780.00) were pledged. The County Schools Superintendent, Mr. Messer spoke and assured the crowd that the county would beg, borrow and steal to provide books and school supplies. William Ryan offered rooms in his hotel for classrooms. The Good Samaritan Hall, The Library and the Union Hotel* also donated space. Classes would be held in the Columia Hall too. A call was put out for all the benches, chairs and tables that citizens could spare. The planned re-opening would be in just ten days.
The Good Samaritan Hall. Site of the High School and Temperance Meetings. SCHS photo. Note that Arroyo Grande had few sidewalks just before the turn of the century and those were wooden. Branch Street was a dusty and muddy place.
Within a week the Board of Control, in a public meeting discussed plans for building a new school house. Public speakers wanted a new building and were suspicious the “Wreckers” on the board would seek to delay rebuilding. Patrick Moore, who owned three rock quarries offered to donate enough stone and the labor to put up the building without charge. Public speakers supported this but the majority of the board voted it down, saying the process would take too long. Within a few days, overheard in Pete Olohan’s saloon, a meeting of the “wreckers” was overheard saying that Olohan had plans to open a brickyard at his property on Bridge Street and it was said that he planned to put Patrick Moore’s quarries out of business.* Without a doubt this news quickly became fodder for discussion around town and further turned public opinion against Willis Buck and his gang. If Pat Moore took note of it, he never said.
Arroyo Grande Recorder:Died: Egan, near Arroyo Grande, Thursday May 19th, Mary Agnes beloved wife of W H Egan a native of Londonderry, Ireland aged 27 years. (Childbirth)
The board decided that using the blueprints from the burnt school would be the most expedient way to begin. Expedient yes, but in 1899 the plans for a building were rudimentary at best and the builders were quite competent in putting up a structure without them. Two of the quarry stone buildings built over the next three years were built using the simplest of sketches numbering two or three pages at most. There would have been a set of simple dimensions, notes on the location of the foundation and perhaps two or three elevations showing the eventual look of the building.
The Reverend Bell of the First United Methodist church who had designed the church on Branch Street was chosen to update and modify the burnt school’s blueprints.
The First United Methodist Church, Arroyo Grande. Photographer unknown.
A call for bids was posted. Builders from counties north and south responded with estimates on the cost of putting up a new school. David Blosser of Santa Maria who came in as the lowest bidder has relinquished his right to claim the contract, stating that he forgot to figure the cost of plastering and that he must withdraw. Will Terry was the next lowest bidder but the board decided to award the contract to William Smith of San Luis Obispo.
Arroyo Grande Herald:John Poole who lives near the Branch School house, has been very ill for several weeks. Thursday he was operated on by Dr’s Norton and Paulding who found a large cancerous growth in his side. The size of the growth is of such a characterthat there is no hope for him.
Smith took the job in hand and quickly order redwood lumber from the mill in Cambria. Oak floors were ordered from San Francisco and would be shipped down by train along with window sashes, kegs of nails, and roofing materials. Stains and paint were supplied by local hardware stores.
Arroyo Grande Herald:Born to Mr and Mrs. JW Bennett, April 17th, a son. Bennett, a son, died, near ArroyoGrande, April 19th, Aged 2 days.
Smith began foundation work on December 4th. The floors were quickly done as the school was built over the existing concrete work left from the destroyed school. Contractor Smith expects to have the school framed up and completed, ready for students on March 1st 1900. The board of control has sent the students home for ten weeks, using the salaries saved to buy new furniture for the building.
San Luis Obispo Superintendant of schools, Mrs Woods published a notice encouraging her district’s schools, the parents and pupils, donate any textbook or school materials they can spare. She stated that they should be dropped off at the county courthouse in San Luis where they would be collected and sent down to Arroyo Grande by train. She said the sign of a good community is the desire to help those less fortunate.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:Osgood Guilty. John Osgood was found guity by a jury in the Superior Court last evening on a charge of seduction. The jury took only two ballots. That will teach the beast.
School districts all over the county, including northern Santa Barbara county all pitched in. Slate boards, erasers, extra desks, paper, pencils, ink and pens came from everywhere. Citizens and parents quickly turned their attention from the plans of the “Wreckers,” though that wouldn’t last long.
Mister Clevenger, publisher and editor of the Herald has made a very generous offer to the students of the high school. Editorial and writing duties for the Christmas edition will be turned over to the students of the school. All the proceeds from the edition will be donated to the students for the purchase of a new telescope to replace the one lost in the fire this October. The students have heartily entered into the spirit of the enterprise and have organized and selected the following committee to manage the holiday edition. Editorial will be Archie Haskins, Amy Hodges and Albert Ore. The advertising committee is made up of Chance Dana, Fred Phoenix, Addie Gibson, Edith Jatta and George Runyon. Archie Beckett, Gay Parsons and Clarence Waterman who will staff the Literary Committee and local reporters are Robert Forkner, Clara Conrad, Phoebe Poole, Albert Fowler and Fanny Taylor.
Stephen Clevenger, wife Edith (Fanny) and son Porter. About 1895. Clevenger was the founder and publisher of the Arroyo Grande Herald (1886) and Santa Maria Times.(1882). Santa Maria Valley Historical Society.
San Luis Obispo Tribune: The Celestials are at War: Some of the celestials declared war and have proceeded to do battle. Yu Kee, a Highbinder from San Francisco fired a shot at a brother chink in the store of Wing Sang Wan on Palm Street. He succeeded in perforating a door. Marshall Cook was called and made a thorough search through the rookeries of chinatown but could not locate him. There are rumors of more trouble to follow in chinatown.
Arroyo Grande Herald:As a fundraising event the students of the high school have put together another party. Next Friday they plan to stage a masked ball to raise money for their school. The student committee has written the invitations for the event to be held at Columbia Hall. The young people expect a large turn out. Much money is expected to be donated towards the high school. The students are to be commended for their public spirit.
Arroyo Grande Herald:Objections by the board of Control have been issued forbidding the students of the high school to us the school name in connection with parties and other events outside the school. Invitations to attend a fund raising masquerade to be given next Friday have been issued by the “Entre Nous Club*. It appears the students will not be suppressed.
The pettiness of the majority on the Board of Control finally tipped the balance. Another citizens meeting was called at the Good Samaritan Hall. About thirty concerned citizens showed up and after some debate a committee was formed for the purpose of exploring the possibility of raising private funds to increase the school budget for 1900. The plan was to raise enough to keep the school in operation. Stephen Clevenger of the Herald was named chairman. Thomas Hodges and Aron Henry along with Clevenger were tasked with exploring the legal issues involved. Another group was tasked with writing a flyer representing the right side of the matter. The flyer would be delivered to every household in the district. That committee was to be chaired by a local school teacher of more than formidable resolve, Mrs E. L. Paulding, Clara to her friends, a woman who could take the measure of any man. It would prove to be a master stroke.
NOTES:
$14,756.00 today.
Arroyo stone, the particular light sandy/red colored sandstone was used in the IOOF Hall, 1903 and Mankins Building, 1904. A walk down Olohan’s Alley shows the rear of several brick and cast iron fronted building built of the same material. Pat Moor’s Quarries would not go out of business just yet.
The Good Samaritan Hall was located where todays City Council Chambers are on Branch Street.
The Union Hall on Bridge Street was across the street from the Odd Fellows Hall.
The grammar school was located on the old Nipomo road, Bridge St, where the Ford agency is today.
Entre Nous: Between ourselves.
Cover Photo: The Old Verde School once located at the head of Corbit Canyon.
Michael Shannon lives in Arroyo Grande, California and writes so his children will know where they came from.
Superintendent Messer says he will not call an election to disincorporate the AGHS district unless the courts compel him too. It is probable the opposition will resort to the courts to force his hand. Frank Newsom and Willis Buck were in town working up the matter yesterday at Olohan’s saloon. The state legislature has ruled that county supervisors cannot tax land owners to support schools which leaves our high schools, in particular, nearly penniless. County school offices do not have nearly enough money to fund all the high schools in the county and ” Little Bald Billy Buck” and his “Wreckers” know that. The legislature is stuffed with rich landowners and the law was no surprise to anyone.
Landowners in San Luis Obispo County are not all paying their school tax. Board of Control members “Lobbied” taxpayers, newspaper publishers and businesses aggressively. They argued that high school curriculum was full of “Fads and Frills.” “Any foreign language classes were ridiculous in an English speaking country and drama, music and art were a waste of time and taxpayers money,” they said. The idea that preparing “Working mens children” for higher education was preposterous. Summer school was a complete and unnecessary luxury .Those students who couldn’t keep up were only good for laboring and teaching them was a waste of money.
Figures from the 1890’s show that the vast majority of children, mostly boys, dropped out of school at 12 to 14 years and went directly to work as my grandfather did. Rural schools in San Luis County had large numbers of students who were immigrants or children of recent immigrants and spoke little or no English. Waves of Portuguese, Japanese, German and Swiss Italian came to California in the 1880’s and ’90’s. They came because of wars and famine in their home countries, a lack of education, grinding poverty and no opportunity to improve their lives. They understood that schools were the key. The Branch School photo shown below lists five Perry kids, one Fink and one Nagagawa. Every one of the 24 remaining kids bears a Portuguese name.
The “Wreckers” didn’t care about these kids. They were only good for labor. Bald Billy Buck, himself a law student at Hastings Law School at the University of California, and who had his tuition partially paid for by Judge Venable, was quoted as saying, “Education is no help to these people. It shouldn’t be put on the shoulders of the successful to pay for it.”
Buck was reducing the uneducated as unworthy. He was referencing the theory of the Helot. Helot was a term used by the Spartans to describe a class of people who were in a sense wage slaves, bound to the soil and assigned to individual property owners to till their holdings; their masters could neither free them nor sell them. The helots had a very limited rights, after paying to their masters a fixed proportion of the produce of the land they worked. In America we refer them to as “Share Croppers,” a state in which the person is only a hair above chattel slavery. After the Civil War ended, Share Cropping was introduced as a way to keep former slaves bound to the land and the plantation owner in business. By the 1890’s Share Cropping had become an institution in America and Willis Buck would have known very well the import of his words.
An article printed in the Oracle quoted Columbia University professor Nicholas Murray Butler as saying, “We need to replace teachers and local school boards opinions on curriculum with education policies set by “College-Educated Bureaucrats.” These administrative “Progressives” forged an alliance with business leaders who liked the idea of top down, expert management of schools. They deplored the idea of local control and wished to lower their taxes by cutting away classes they deemed “Useless and Wasteful.”*
The “Wreckers were certainly aware of a reform movement that advocated replacing women teachers with men. “Feminization” of teachers was a major misstep according to William Rainey Harper, president of the university of Chicago. When Chicago teachers complained, that their wages had been frozen for twenty years and they deserved a living wage, Harper replied that women in the teaching profession should be glad they made as much money as his maid, who worked harder than they did and deserved her money, inferring, of course, that female teachers did not.
Under the guise of “Reform,” business leaders stated that non-university-schooled teachers were not qualified to make autonomous decisions, write lesson plans or discipline children within their own classrooms.* Reform leaders thought that “Normal Schools” gave only the most rudimentary education to women teachers and that graduates were not, thus, fully qualified to manage their classrooms.
Local people may have had just a simple education but they could read. The back and forth agreements were a staple of the local papers. Other county papers watched and commented on the Board of Control’s doings too. Though big city papers didn’t write about local news, they were readily available. Daily papers from San Francisco were brought down by train from the city by the Southern Pacific railroad which had a depot in San Luis Obispo. You could read a paper from Chicago or New York just a day or two old. Newspapers were the only mass outlet for news and were thoroughly read. Readers would not have been unaware of educational doings in other cities. Thinking that people in 1899 were completely unaware of world events would be a mistake. Disincorporation of the high school was a community wide concern and it was clear that the moneyed interests, the big landowners and their crony’s meant to kill the school.
Supporters of the high school were counting on a recent law passed in Sacramento which gave women who were eligible the right to vote in school elections. Governor Gage promptly vetoed it. He apparently stands with the Republican school Wreckers here. Surely women voters, mothers and fathers of children, would have tipped the balance for the school in an honest election. The last one was not honest. People knew that the ballot boxes had been manipulated. The head of the election commission had a vested interest in seeing the school fail as he controlled a very large ranch in rural Arroyo Grande.As Stephen Clevenger said in the Herald, we know because everyone knows that the government can’t keep a secret for five seconds, something that holds true today
Born 100 Years too Soon. Illustration: J R Williams.
Arroyo Grande Herald:Miss MaudGriebarrived in this place yesterday where she will spend the summer before retuning to Stanford.
Maud Grieb. Saturday Night Club. Stanford University Yearbook..
The immediate need was for donations to make up the nearly one thousand dollar shortfall in the budget in order to keep the school open until spring 1901. The Wreckers who had a majority of one on the board of control had lowered Professor Parsons salary to $65.00 a year hoping he would resign. He didn’t, so they lowered it to $40.00 and he did. So did the two teachers. They next hired a notorious local drunk and ne’er-do-well named Stringfellow to be the principal and not one new teacher. The students began to skip school. Clara Paulding saw Cliffie Carpenter and Helen Grieb walking arm in arm past Miller’s Stable and blacksmiths shop and asked them why they weren’t in school. Cliffie replied, “He doesn’t teach us anything and the boys like Tom Meherin, Louis Phillips and Charley Phoenix* jump out of the windows and go smoke down by the creek. There is nothing for us to do.” Clara shook her finger at the girls and said, “If you don’t stay in school there will be no school. Take your knitting or a book to read but please stay in school and I will tell the boys’ fathers, who will strip a piece from their backside if they are caught again.” She was as good as her word. All three fathers were supporters of the school. Meherin and Phoenix were both large landowners and had already made substantial donations to the school fund as had the Phillips Brothers.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:About 9 o’clock last evening Marshall Cook arrested one of the denizens of Chinatown who operates a house of ill-fame. She was released on bond of $50.00 by Judge Egan.($1,500.00 today)
The fund to support the school was quickly raised and the class of 1901 was assured of graduation. What kind of education they got was up for debate as the new principal did not change his stripes one bit. Nevertheless the class would graduate in the spring.
Arroyo Grande Herald:1898: Mister John Corbit a well-known citizen of this district is being mentioned in connection as a candidate for county Sheriff. He will make the strongest possible candidate that the party could put up.
The Honorable John Corbit From County Cork Ireland. B. 1832, D. 1912. Photo from Pat Moores photo album. Shannon Family.
Arroyo Grande Herald:24th June, 1899: At Oak Park, Mr and Mrs Willis Buck, born, a son.
Arroyo Grande Herald:25th June, 1899: At Oak Park, Mr and Mrs Willis Buck, a son. Died.
The members of the save the school committee tasked with exploring the legal issues surrounding the closing of the school went to work. Three local businessmen, Thomas Hodges, Amos Henry and the publisher of the Herald, Stephen Clevenger began looking into any legal issues they thought might give them an opening into reversing the decisions of the Board of Control.
Amos Henry was a young father with a 5 year old son, Daniel. At 31 he was successful farmer and lived and farmed on what would become Mason Street. He and his wife Aurelia were both community mended. Amos went on to become county assessor and was active in many organizations such as the IOOF. He was cerainly concerned for the future education of his little boy.
Thomas Hodges was also a farmer and grew fruit trees on the Arroyo Grande road southwest of town off todays Halcyon Road. His farm was where the mobile home parks are today. He and his wife Sarah had six children. All educated in Arroyo Grande schools. Thomas’s daughter Rose taught at Los Berros school in the 1890’s. Well known was their son Virgil who Chronicled life around the turn of the century with his camera. Virgil who always listed himself as an artist, left us an incomparable record of photographs of our town and the people who lived here. Virgil was a 1897 graduate of the high school.
Virgil Hodges, left and friend on the Pismo Road. After the turn of the century. Virgil Hodges Photo.
Arroyo Grande Herald:It is hightime the responsible citizens of the Arroyo Grande district arise and stamp into dust this whole hissing nest of vipers trying to dismantle education and bring anarchy to our school system.
After the citizens meeting at the Good Samaritan Hall, Mrs Paulding began going door to door, buttonholing anyone would would listen to her about the value of higher education. Carefully skipping around the manure dotting the dirt streets, pinching her flounce and lifting it to keep her hem out of the muck as she knocked on door after door. Some remained closed to her but most opened up and listened to what she had to say.
The flyer she carried was headed with the phrase, “The Plain Facts.” It went on to say that it had been requested that the flyer be circulated by the friends of the high school. In it they encouraged readers to take a look at the statements being made by the board of control; to wit:
1.That it is not possible to continue the high school because of the dissatisfaction of the people.
2. The majority of the board of control are opposed to the continuance of said school. (Six to five.)
3. As the high school district is so large as to make it impossible for students to travel to and from the school, property owners should not be taxed to pay for the school as no students would be wiling to travel that far to attend.
Mrs Paulding pointed out that there was no dissatisfaction by the public except on the part of the board of control whose six majority office holders were in fact large property owners who represented considerably less than a third of the district’s students but more than 60% of its land.
She also pointed out that 80% of all students who attended the school lived within four and a half miles of the school, a distance easily traveled by horse or wagon. The Patchett family farmed and ranched on land adjacent to Willis Buck. She stated they had no problem getting their children to school. In fact, the Fink children were students who traveled more than eight miles to school. She mentioned the Phoenix children and the Harloes who lived fifteen miles away on their ranches but who also maintained houses in town. Both families had homes off Bridge street which were within easy walking distance of the school. Ex-supervisor Moore and his wife Sarah also provided rooms for children during the week.
Clara said it was clear that there was a great deal of support for the school as evidenced by the funds the committee had raised to support it.
Mrs Paulding was quick to point out that the school had twenty-four students currently attending the school that came from these outlying district and that there were an equal number who would graduate from the eighth grade in May ready to enter the high school in the fall.*
She also said that without a high school diploma no student would be able to enter the state’s universities. There was already talk from the State Board of Education that the Arroyo Grande high school would lose its accreditation over the propose disenfranchisement fight.*
The opposition had also been saying that the grammar schools curriculum had been corrupted and that the Normal Schools had indicated that no graduate would be qualified to enter there. Clara was quite clear that this story being put about by the Wreckers was an outright lie and could easily be disproved.
Arroyo Grande:Died, Oliver Taylor, age 70
The three men working up a legal case against the board of control were ready to go to court. They had been working with the county District Attorney to draw up a bill of particulars stating the various crimes and misdemeanors of the Wreckers. A hearing would be held in the San Luis Obispo courthouse.
The Herald also posited that since nearly all of the grammar schools in the district had with withdrawn from the union high school, their seats on the board of control should be vacated as they no longer represented the school.
Arroyo Grande Oracle:An automobile passed through town yesterday on its way to Solano. It runs by steam.
Everything came to a head in September of 1899. The “Wreckers, by a single vote of the board of supervisors reduced the budget for Arroyo Grande’s high school to the point where it simply could no longer operate.
The Citizens Committee to Save the School quickly raised enough money through subscriptions to make up the budget shortfall and thus ensured that the school would remain open until June of 1900.
Up at the county courthouse Oliver Pence, the attorney representing the “Friends” was meeting with County District Attorney Arch Campbell who had won election the year before, defeating Fred Dorn who was no friend of the school. The Tribune wondered what kind of strategy they were cooking up behind closed doors. Willis Buck, who happened to be in San Luis was quoted as saying, “I will not show the white feather,* no threats from the committee will stop us from closing the high school. It is a burden to all taxpayers and must go.” Buck, Miossi, and Donovan are having a lively time of it said the Tribune.
Buck was soon to find out what they were up to. On Sept. 14 the district attorney issued a citation ordering W. B. Buck, et al, to appear in court on Wednesday the 20th to show cause why they should not be removed from office and judgement of $ 500.00* entered against each of the board members who had voted to reduce the budget and close the school.
Both parties appeared before Judge Unangst in superior court at 10 am. The “Wreckers’ immediately requested a continuance citing too little time to prepare their case. Judge Unangst granted the request and set a new hearing for the 22nd. That too was postponed for the same reason though Judge Unangst was not pleased with the continued delays by the “Obstructionists.” The opening of the trial was now set for Wednesday the 28th.
Outside the courthouse, Bernard Miossi, who represents the Pismo school district on the board of control of the high school said that the board would hold a meeting to formally close the school on Saturday. Daniel Donovan who is a member of the board from the two Los Berros schools agreed with Miossi that the school should not continue. They both said, “This will be an exciting meeting; the school, will, be closed however They can’t stop us, we have the majority.”
Except that it wasn’t. The citizens committee showed up at the Columbia Hall in force. They far outnumbered tose who wanted to close. It was a standing room turnout. Many fine speeches were given opposing the closing of the school. Mrs E. L. Paulding took the board to task stating that what they were doing was illegal and if they went ahead she would see them in jail for breaking their oath of office. At the end of the night the majority, the “Wreckers” voted to table the motion to close until after the superior court made its ruling. That trial was due to begin on Thursday the 28th and the majority said they were ready and would prevail.
Reported Expressly for the Tribune by P. A. H. Ararta in superior court the Hon. Edward P. Unangst, Judge, September 28th, 1899.
Plaintiff R. B, Musick* vs. Willis B. Buck et al. The defendants request for a trial by jury denied by Judge Unangst. The judge stating that he had had enough delays. The defendants then demanded that they be tried by separately. Denied again. Judge Unangst was visibly angry and threatened the defendants with contempt for their attempt to delay the proceedings. The defendants then asked for a continuance of five days on account of the absence of a material witness, viz: Mrs. A. C. S. Woods. Motion again denied. The following witnesses testified for the plaintiffs. D. Newsom, Albert Fowler, Mrs Clara Dudley Edwards Paulding, A. Slack, Geo. Balaam, Frank Swigert, Robert English, and A F Parsons.
David Newsom, was the son of Frank Newsom who built the first school at Newsom Springs but who was opposed to the high school. There must have been some interesting conversations around the kitchen table up in Newsom’s canyon.
Others testifying for the plaintiffs were Albert Fowler, the father of three young children was a farmer, Albert Slack an accountant, George Balaam, a Gensler (Goose breeder), Frank Swigart, a farmer, Robert English,* Arroyo Grande’s undertaker and A F Parsons, the county surveyor. They were all parents of children in school.
The missing witness, Adelaide Woods was the San Luis county superintendant of schools. She was the first woman elected to that position. She was a graduate of the state normal school in San Jose, the future San Jose State University and had taught a year at the Alma school, San Jose and two years in Eureka, Humboldt county. She taught at the Court school in San Luis before being elected to the job as superintendant. In fact, she was the first lady elected to any office in the history of the county. She was just 35 years old and had been elected in 1898 . She had been instrumental in collecting furnishings, books and other supplies for the Arroyo Grande Grammar school after it was destroyed by fire. It would be interesting to know what the “Wreckers” had in mind when they asked her to testify. It isn’t likely she would have been in favor of closing the high school. She had been elected and began serving the previous year and its easy to imagine her thought process. She had to uphold her office, an elected office to boot, and her primary job was supporting education. It’s difficult to imagine what the “Obstructionists” were thinking. It was extremely unlikely she would have anything to say to support the actual closing of a school. She made herself scarce.
When testimony was concluded, judge Unangst continued the trial to the next day, Friday the 29th for closing arguments. He said he was curious what the “Wreckers” might say in closing as they had produced no witnesses for their own defense.
San Luis Obispo Superior Courthouse, Fourth of July, 1898.
Late on Friday morning Judge Unangst ordered that the case of Musick vs. W. B. Buck be called. The attorney for the plaintiffs, Oliver Pence rose and informed the judge that the parties had reached an agreement and moved that the action be dismissed without prejudice* , and without costs to either party. Judge Unangst took a long moment then asked the attorney for the “Wreckers” if they agreed. With the answer in the affirmative he dismissed the case.
Overnight a deal had been reached. When the remainder of the case was presented to Buck, he realized he was done. State law required that an elected board could not dissolve itself. Elected officials, sworn to duty could not, as part of that duty, vote to disband themselves. In effect, closing the school was a crime under state law as they were duty bound to continue education at the high school level. The schemers would be liable for fines and possible incarceration if found guilty. Willis B. Buck was forced to show the White Feather. The high school was saved.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:Popular school teacher Miss Mollie O’Conner and several of her friends were up from Arroyo Grande yesterday.
In Arroyo Grande an election was immediately held in which new trustees were elected. The three remaining grammar schools and the high school board voted that Frank Parsons be rehired as principle and Amos Henry was then voted in as president of the school board. The withdrawal of eight of the grammar schools in the south county now meant that the individual school would no longer use their budgets to help support the high school. They would also no longer receive revenues from the high school which would reduce their operating costs. The new high school board, according to Amos Slack, the district accountant, needed to establish a fee for out of district students to attend the school. On the recommendation of Mr. Slack a charge of $2.50* a month for each student was so ordered.
The withdrawn grammar schools almost immediately began to hear complaints from parents that wanted their children to attend high school. What once cost them nothing suddenly became a burden on their pocketbooks and they let the trustees of their schools know it. To use an old phrase used at the time, they had “Shot themselves in the foot” or, as the case may be, their collective feet.
Those that followed the lead of the “Wreckers” now suffered with them. Over the next few years all the grammar schools that had jumped ship came crawling back and rejoined the Union High School District.
The High School Citizens Committee: The citizens committee in defense of the high school feels it must commend Mr. Clevenger for his unstinting support of the school these last nine years. His defense in preserving the school and defeating the opposition cannot go unnoticed. The committee takes great pleasure in saying a word in behalf of his generous and unstinting work. There is nothing that lends general prosperity to the common welfare of a community like an active local paper, one that is in harmony with the town and its beneficent institutions. Without Mr Clevenger, the high school would have been closed some time past.
The Herald Recorder Building erected by Stephen Clevenger in 1897. Arroyo Grande Herald photo. 1963
Arroyo Grande Herald:The Herald says that the class of 1901 of the Arroyo Grande High School will hold its commencement exercises at the Columbia Hall next Friday evening, May 31st. Doctor Thos. Hoyer will be pleased to give the commencement address The members of the class consider themselves very fortunate in having a school from which to graduate. The four* young ladies of the class are Mary v. Keown, Lou F. Parsons, A Gelka Barcella and Lorena B. HaskinsThey will be tendered a reception by the other three classes at the Union Hall this evening at 7:00 O’clock.
The program is as follows:
Song, “The Bugler”, John “Jack” Shannon*
Recitation: The Hen with One Chicken by Miss Stella Sims.
Coon Song; Six Girls*
“The Kitchen Clock,” Duet, Hazel Miller, May Clevenger
Selection, Orchestra.
Recitation: The Little Runaway, Florence Lynam.
Song: The Boot Black*, Eight Boys.
The Class Colors are Green and Pink.
Master of ceremonies is Miss Belle Bowden. Assistant Principal
So the “Wreckers” slunk back into their caves like the snakes that they were and nothing more was heard from them. Willing to destroy an educational opportunity for the children of the Arroyo Grande Valley they received their comeuppance from a dedicated citizens group led an educated woman whose life had taught her that you must take no prisoners when it came to matters of principle.
Herald Recorder:The high school will be constructed on new lines. This ought not to be such a hard job with such workers as Mr. Newsom, Mr. Fowler and Mrs. Paulding at the helm. The high school district and the people will fall right in and carry them out. We must have no more “Dog in the manger practice.”
Arroyo Grande High School, built 1904
Arroyo Grande High School today numbers more than 2,000 students. It is a California Distinguished school and boasts a 96% graduation rate. All of this grown from a tiny school with no building of its own founded in 1895. Today, one of the districts middle schools is named for Clara Edwards Paulding’s daughter, Ruth who taught for over thirty years in the district. Ruth Paulding taught both my father and my uncle. My children both attended Paulding middle school. The Paulding family home is now a state park museum and is open to the public.
On a final note. History like all of life is a very flexible thing. The issues written about here are still with us today in perhaps a slightly different form but nonetheless they are still bones of contention. Educational issues are never truly finally fixed. This has been an extremely interesting story to write about. All I can say is that, be like Clara, do your homework, work hard at educating yourself about educational issues and don’t be afraid. History tends to treat women as subtext, but be assured that, just as today, they were a serious factor in 1901 Arroyo Grande.
Miss Ruth Paulding.
Notes:
*The cover photo is of the new grammar school that replaced the one destroyed by fire. It was razed in 1931.
*Professor Nicholas Murray Butlers opinion that schools should be run by “College Educated Bureaucrats” is now the norm.
*Administrative bureaucrats posited that discipline should only be meted out by “Qualified Professionals.”
*Neither Tom Meherin, Charley Phoenix or Louis Phillips graduated with their class in 1901 though they were all from prominent and well off families and their fathers were supporters of the high school.
*The High School did lose its accreditation. My grandmother, Annie Gray graduated from the eighth grade in the spring of 1901 from Arroyo Grande grammar and would begin as a freshman that fall. Because she intended to enter the University of California she was forced to travel down to Santa Maria for high school where she graduated in 1904. She was a graduate of Cal, class of 1908.
*$500.00 in 1900 money is the equivalent of more than $18,000.00 today. It would have been a devastating fine.
*The white feather is a widely recognized symbol. It has, among other things, represented cowardice or conscientious pacifism; as in A. E. W. Mason’s 1902 book “The Four Feathers”. In Britain during the First World War, it was often given to males out of uniform by women to shame them publicly into signing up for the slaughterhouse in France. The true origins of the term are lost to history but Billy Buck certainly knew it was meant to show cowardice.
*R. Musick was a rancher in the upper Arroyo Grande and was the father of well known author and historian Madge Musick Ditmas who wrote a column on local history for the Herald for over thirty years . He is credited with being one of the county’s first grape growers.
*Robert English the town undertaker displayed my great-grandfather John Edward Shannon in his coffin behind the window of his parlor on Branch Street in 1924. I went to school with his grandson Jack, who is my life long friend.
*Communications marked as ‘without prejudice’ cannot be used by the other party as evidence in court. This means that parties can speak openly about the matters in dispute without the risk of the other party using that information against them later.
*The $2.50 a month is roughly equal to $90. 00 today. A serious levy for 1900.
*The four young ladies that graduated in 1901 were the remains of a freshman class of 18, including 6 boys.
*Coon song or “Turkey in the Straw” is a folk tune that been around in the United States for almost 200 years. With lyrics clearly intended to parody the speech of African-Americans in the rural South, it became a staple of minstrel shows and blackface acts into the twentieth century. It was a popular black-faced minstrel show song and one of the most popular sheet music covers for the song is dominated by an image of a caricatured black man. In sum, it appears that most credible sources date “Old Zip Coon” as the earlier song. “Turkey in the Straw” is adapted from it. The song illustrates the systemic and casual racism of the time. The civil war was part of the experience for many Arroyo Grandeans, many having fought in or migrated west from the border states. A large number of citizens had come out of Missouri after the war and brought prejudices with them.
*The Boot Black is another racially centered song. History shows that though it seems that no real changes have been made in our country’s conversation with race the opposite is true. The kind of overt racism presented in this music would not be tolerated today, at least in public.
*Prejudice against the Chinese was also extreme at the time. The Chinese Exclusion Act was approved on May 6, 1882. It was the first significant law restricting immigration into the United States. In the spring of 1882, the Chinese Exclusion Act was passed by Congress and signed by President Chester A. Arthur.Jan 17, 1882. Following the passing of the Chinese Exclusion Act, a period known as the “Driving Out” era was born. In this period, anti-Chinese Americans physically forced Chinese communities to flee to other areas.
*You will note that my grandfather Jack Shannon sang at the 1901 graduation ceremony though he never attended a single day of high school. He also played on the high school baseball team. Such was life in small town America at the turn of the twentieth century.
*And finally, Little Bald Willis Buck never went to law school. He lost and the judge never paid up. He died in Avila Beach, CA in 1933. In the ultimate irony, all of his three children went to high school.
*Patrick Moore ran for supervisor against Gilliam in 1902 and reclaimed his seat by a large margin.
*On a final note, the author went to school with the descendants of nearly all the families written about in this article. Patchett, Fink, Harloe, Phoenix, Donovan, Newsom, Fowler, Miossi, Jatta, Moore, Gray, English, Swigert and the others who still reside in our county.
Michael Shannon lives in Arroyo Grande and is a graduate of Arroyo Grande high school as were his father and uncle, 1928 and 1930. Both of his sons are AGHS grads also. He, his wife and his brother and sister-in-law all taught in the school district.
People prefer to find order and beauty in the past. The heritage business is devoted to making sure they do. Textbooks are written which carefully polish the past until it shines.The silk ropes strung before the exhibit are meant to keep you out. The partition is to block your view. There is no place you can stand to see all the parts at once. Much of history is the shadow of somthing, blurred, which fails to to mark the place where an event, almost familiar, once was. Much history has runoff like water after a storm. It’s blown by the wind into nothing. Sometimes, from the tail of the eye an image appears. You have caught an instant of transparency, then the present draws the veil. This is a tiny drop of that local history, long, forgotten.
Arroyo Grande Herald: Sept. 10, 1898.
There are a number of citizens who are anxious on one ground or another that the educational facilities of the Arroyo Grande region should not have a high school….
So began the editorial laying out of the back and forth war between the factions who were at odds over the continuation of Arroyo Grande High School.
Arroyo Grande Herald: There will be a third stakes race Saturday at the Arroyo Grande Chataqua grounds between Jake See’s “Jennie T” and Will Heath’s “Perrine,” an eighth of a mile for a $ 50.00 purse. ($1,9750.00 )
In the very beginning Don Francisco Branch had sent for his sister, asking her to come out to California to take in hand the teaching of his children and those of his employees sometime before 1848. She made the trip from Scipio, New York to California by sail from New York to Panama, crossed the isthmus by mule and sailed north to California arriving in San Francisco in 1848. Escorted by a party of Rancheros returning to their ranches in the Cow Counties, she arrived safely after a trip of around 7,000 miles. She spent three to five months on the trip. She survived Bandidos, yellow fever, malaria, bad food, sea sickness and a great deal of discomfort. The trip cost between three and four hundred dollars. Getting to the west coast cost roughly $11,000.00 in todays dollars. Francis Branch could afford it. Most travelers were wealthy enough to pay their own way. This meant that most immigrants had some education and important skill in order to pay their own way. The poor stayed home.
Don Francisco Ziba Branch, sailor, mountain man, trapper storekeeper and Ranchero. Litho Print from 1860’s.
Miss Branch taught in the Branch home of her brother for five years. She did not speak Spanish, though it was the universal language of California before the gold rush. She learned quickly enough. She taught basic reading, writing and arithmetic along with drawing and music. The children taught her Spanish and how to ride horseback in the Californio style where women rode astride like a man. Once her students were old enough they were sent up to San Francisco to be “Finished.”
Arroyo Grande school, 1867. The first after the township was formed. SCHS photo
In 1867 Francisco Branch deeded a plot of land on todays Nevada street and a small wooden schoolhouse was built there. It was the first.
Arroyo Grande grew exponentially after the War Between the States. As always, wars create a world of widows and orphans. Add to this hundreds of thousands of veterans of the brutal fighting it is no wonder people felt the need to pick up and go. Go west it was and many came here.
Large landowners in California, the original Rancheros had little choice in finding a way to profit from their vast holdings. With statehood, organized government demanding taxes and the decline of trade with the east, the Ranchos were sold or were broken up, subdivided and along with active boosters who advertised nationwide, small farm took on a new importance. Many of the new residents were veterans. They brought their families with them and were familiar with schools in Ohio, Indiana and Illinois, where many came from, the wanted the same opportunities for children here.
Arroyo Grande Herald:The Philllips boys have shot a Condor in the upper Lopez. It measured over nine feet wingtip to wingtip.
The teachers were no longer adventurers or men and women who had some education that supplied the first decades of schooling in the Arroyo Grande valley but graduates of the Normal Schools. The California State Normal School was the first teaching college in state, founded on May 2, 1862. The school later evolved into San José State University in San Jose. The southern branch campus evolved into the University of California, Los Angeles.
California State Normal School, San Jose. 1888. Calisphere photo archive
The San Jose school was created when the State of California took over a normal school that educated San Francisco teachers in association with that city’s high school system. This school was founded in 1857 and was generally known as either the San Francisco Normal School or Minns Evening Normal School.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:County hunters asked the Board of Supervisors to set a bounty on Blue Jays. The birds eat the eggs of quail and other game birds and reduce the populations. They have also been known to kill small children. The board will take this under advisement.
Normal schools were developed and built primarily to train elementary level teachers for the public schools. The term “normal school” is based on the French école normale, a sixteenth-century school with practice classrooms where model teaching practices were taught to teacher candidates.
San Jose State Normal School students about 1896. Calisphere
The Anna S. C. Blake Manual Training School, opened in 1889 was located in Santa Barbara, taught home economics and skills like sewing and cooking. Sloyd, a Scandinavian system of handicraft education, was also offered at the training school. Almost all of the original teachers in our town were graduates of one of these two schools. Margaret Phoenix Harloe, Hattie and Mamie Tyler, Molly O’Conner Moore, Gladys Walker Sullivan, and young women of the Rice, Poole, Conrad, Carpenter and Ide families.
Education was important to families with children. They wanted the best they could get but large landowners, businessmen and those with no children in the home were far less concerned about education and much more concerned with the taxes that supported the schools and that’s where the trouble started.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:The proposal to apply for a Carnegie Library in this place has met with stiff opposition from certain taxpayers. The application has been tabled until more study can be done. The opposing parties claim there is not the slightest reason to provide free books to the public.They state that it is a well know fact that excessive reading leads to sloth and indolence.
In 1893 when the high school was proposed a vote was held using the Australian voting system. It simply required that the voter write yes or no on a slip of paper and drop it in the box provided. There was no requirement that voters be registered only that they be personally known by the clerk accepting ballots. The system worked quite well as there were less than sixteen thousand people in the entire county. Arroyo Grande had a rough population of about 466. The demographic area covered the entire lower and upper Arroyo Grande valley. Oak Park, Los Berros, Cienega, and Oso Flaco, the Pismo and Nipomo votes were counted as well. A small population but they had pretensions.
The Arroyo Grande Herald: Saturday, June 3, 1893.“From the official returns of the election of May 27th, 1893 proposing the formation of a Union High School District a large aggregate of the votes tallied from the districts proposed a large percentage, 181 yea, 11 nay, the election is hereby carried. The nay votes came from the following districts; Arroyo Grande, three, Branch, two, Oak Park, four, West Los Berros, one and Los Berros one. All other districts were carried in a convincing fashion. We will have a high school.
In those Nay votes were the seeds of rebellion which began showing itself very quickly. Each of the smaller elementary schools would pay a portion of the tax needed to fund the high school as the California Supreme Court had ruled that taxing landowners to pay for high schools was illegal under the states constitution. It only took a few years for the big ranchers to figure out that if they could get the small elementary school districts to leave the union of schools which supported the high school, the school would fail for lack of funds. A number of them went to work. They weren’t shy with their opinions either. The newspapers of the south county reported on the doings on a regular basis. The Arroyo Grande Herald, owned by Stephen Clevenger who had arrived in Arroyo Grande from Missouri by way of Santa Cruz, promptly founded a wife, Edith Finney with whom he started his first paper there. He came down to Arroyo Grande, started a new paper for which he was owner, editor and publisher. Known as the Weekly Herald, Clevenger quickly demonstrated that he was without fear when it came to reporting the doings in the valley. He was definitely pro school and went after the men he called “Wreckers” with a vengeance.
Arroyo Grande Herald: Lodge no. 258, I. O. O. F.The Angel of death has invaded our mystic circle and removed from us our beloved brother, I. D. Miller. In his death our order has lost an active and useful member and the community a useful person. A.F. Parsons, Secretary.
Saturday go to town, Branch Street, Arroyo Grande. Photo, California Historical Society. Town constable Henry Llewellyn was shot in the doorway of the Capitol Saloon, left, and died the next day in the Ryan Hotel. Ryan Hotel is the large building distant left. Peter “Pete” Olohan’s building is the tall building on the right. There are eight saloons in this photo. Saturday afternoon was shopping day for the rural ranchers and farmers. A time to stock up on necessities, get the local gossip and scheme and deal politically.
Self styled important men objected to the high school and met at Pete Olohan’s saloon on Branch Street to hack out a way to get the school closed. Sitting around a table on a Saturday afternoon while their wives did the weekly shopping, they pulled on cheap cigars and passed a bottle around and discussed strategies for closing the school and getting themselves out from under the burden of paying a tax they didn’t agree with. Daniel Donovan owner of substantial acreage in the west Los Berros section, Ed Newsom, Hotel owner and farmer from the Newsom Springs ranch on the old Santa Manuela Rancho, Bernard Miossi owner of Sycamore Springs and Willis Buck who was ranching on the Corral de Piedra and Oak Park area planned a campaign to relieve themselves of the property taxes that supported schools, particularly the new high school. Sitting with them was Judge Venable from San Luis Obispo who controlled the big Biddle Ranch in the northern end of the valley.Their scheme was to find a legal way to close down the high school district, and if no strictly legal way could be found, well….
The Newsom Sulfur Hot Springs Hotel, 1887. Calisphere photo
Arroyo Grande Herald:Charles S. Clark M.D. Professionalcalls attended to, day or night.*
The group chose young Willis Buck as their spokesman as he was studying law and being advised by Judge Venable and apparently had a big chip on his shoulder. It pretty evident that Stephen Clevenger of the Herald didn’t care for him as evidenced by this description which he published soon after the meeting at Olohan’s. “Little Wrecker Billy Buck” or “Little Baldy Billy Buck” were terms the paper used to get under his skin, both of which just made him angry. Clevenger kept it up.
The Wreckers put the first part of their scheme in motion soon after the September 4th, 1897 meeting at Olohan’s. The began to pressure the clerks of the board who held the elementary schools vote to terminate the Union with the high school, thus depriving the school of it’s main source of income, the districts elementary schools who paid into the high school operating fund. They also called upon County Superintendent Messer to schedule a special vote to elect a new High School board. No regular vote was scheduled but political pressure and the thought that the voters, all men of property of course, would support the school as they had done in 1893 when it was first approved, convinced Messer this election would end the same way. Women who were likely the most concerned for their children were still more than twenty years away from suffrage and were excluded.
The third leg of the plan was to pressure the voters of the old fifth supervisorial district to vote out the incumbent, Patrick Moore. He had announced for a third four year term and was known to be a supporter of all schools.
Patrick Moore was born in Cavan, Cavan, Ireland and had immigrated with nearly his entire family to the old Guadalupe Rancho in the Santa Maria area. A very successful rancher, farmer and… as he always listed on his census forms, Capitalist. He owned wide swaths of property in the Santa Maria and Arroyo Grande area. He had spent eight years as a supervisor in was was still known in the later nineties as the “Bloody fifth,” a sobriquet that was very well deserved. Hardly a week passed without a report of a murder, Saloon shooting, accidental death by gunshot, crushed by accident, dismemberment, fratricide and the killings of wives, children and husbands and neighbors. The newspapers from the Paso Robles Leader to the Arroyo Grande Herald faithfully listed the mayhem. If a person survived all the above, they still might be poisoned, killed by bad food or eating too many green Cherry’s. They could be shot in cold blood by the road agents and bandits which infested the still rural “Cow Counties.” For children, dying before five was also a distinct possibility. Horses routinely caused mayhem, kicking men to death, crushing and running away with their owners happened all the time. A spooked horse reared and then backed a buggy with its driver and her infant daughter over the side of the railroad bridge and miracle of miracle, no one was hurt unless it was the horses dignity. There is is only one recorded legal hanging in the county, all the rest, and there were many over the previous 45 years, had been impromptu. The latest, a lynching of a fifteen year old and his father from the Pacific Coast Railroad bridge in 1886 by “men unknown.” A curious part of that event is that the men were certainly not unknown and were in fact, some of the leading citizens of Arroyo Grande. An older man who spoke at my grammar school when I was 11, told us of his father being called out at night to assist in the lynching of the man and his son. He said the men doing the hanging were known to all, their names were an open secret. A state detective was ordered in to investigate the extra-legal murders but interviews with the towns citizens yielded no one iota of information on the identities of the men who did the deed. Mrs. Eldridge’s daughter Missouri was one of the children who witnessed the dangling bodies the next morning on the way to school.
The Arroyo Grande Herald: Many Children See Bodies.Missouri Eldridge, chattering gaily with her chum approached the bridge over which the children crossed each day to the schoolhouse. “Oh, Zoo! There the most terrible thing on the bridge.” Exclaimed one of the group of breathless girls rushing back to her. But Missouri was not to be plagued. “Don’t be silly.” she replied sedately. “You are only trying to fool me because this is April Fools Day.” Then, her eyes widened as she stared past the chalk white faces of the other girls for she saw they were not fooling, indeed. She saw, hanging from the bridge, the bodies of a man and a boy, hung during the night. She ran home to tell her mother.**
No legal measure was ever filed against them. My own great-grandfather was known to carry the Smith and Wesson 41 caliber pistol he had used as a Santa Clara County deputy sheriff in his front pocket on occasion. Very little law enforcement existed beyond the town constable. Nefarious deeds were seldom punished. Most citizens seemed to take a certain Ho Hum attitude about it all. What is common fare is barely noted, even today.
The offending bridge. Home to buggy accidents, impromptu lynchings and even an occasional train. Pacific Coast Railroad, photographer unknown.
The bridge was one of only two ways to cross Arroyo Grande creek. There were few houses on the east side an area that was still mostly small holdings and farms. The dirt paths and buggy crossing illustrate the fact that it was routinely used by pedestrians, wagons and the train. This bridge would be washed out in the floods of 1911.
Arroyo Grande Herald: September 8th, 1897:Yesterday at the Cienega just south of Arroyo Grande near supervisor Moore’s home a sad accident occurred . The ten year od son of Mr and Mrs Costa who live at the old stagecoach stop along the Nipomo road was playing with a loaded gun which accidentely discharged killing his infant brother. The parents of the children were away from the home at the time. The Coroners inquest was in accordance with the above facts.
The Costa home, lower Bridge Street and Nipomo Road, late 1880’s. Arroyo Grande Herald Recorder, Costa Family Photo.
In 1898, the superintendent of county schools realized that he was up against real opposition to the Arroyo Grande high school. Screeching and whining had finally reached the point that anti-school “wreckers” were on the march and meant to throttle the high school once and for all. They were aiming for Supervisor Patrick Moore and citizens wondered where they would strike after that.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:Mrs Strobridge will have her yellow dog safely in her possession. City Marshall Cook confirmed her that his brother, City Marshall of Morgan Hill has found the dog and arrested the man who swiped him. The yellow dog will be brought back to this county and will be made to tell what he knows.
It was reported that Supervisor Moore would sit on the Dias at the courthouse in San Luis Obispo and with a sphinx-like expression and was rarely readable until he made his decision. He was also immune to bribery. As a supporter of education and a rich man, he was bulletproof when it came to lending support and his personal fortune to the school district. For many years and into the decade to come he consistently used his money to pay tuition for boys and girls who were off to school to become professionals. Numbers of young women including my grandmother were recipients of his largesse. No school was ever given his name but a local elementary school carries the name of a young woman who became a teacher thanks to Patrick and Sarah Moore’s generosity. Obviously in order to guarantee the success of their scheme, the Wreckers had to boot him out of office.
Annie Shannon nee Gray, The honorable Patrick Moore and Mary “Molly O” O’Connor schoolteacher. 1900. Shannon Family Photo.
The election of 1898 saw many scenes that would be entirely familiar today. The Wreckers put up a candidate named John Gilliam. Gilliam had been the supervisor for the Santa Margarita district but was tossed out after a single term. Moving from that district to Pismo Beach he declared himself a candidate for the fifth against the incumbent, the Honorable Patrick Moore the two time holder of the seat. There were three challengers initially but after some closed door meetings two of them “graciously” withdrew their names from consideration. The Herald reported this incident with more than a touch of snark, stating that “What promises were made is unknown but it is certain they were made and if Gilliam wins will be fulfilled.”
Arroyo Grande Herald: October 8th, 1898.Say! It was rather nice for Fowler and Eddy to step down and out and make way for Gilliam wasn’t it? Such exhibitions of “Good for the order” are so seldom met with.”
Pat Moore was a popular man in the fifth and was considered a fiscal conservative. In the way that politics works, his record as such was used against him. In the last quarter of ’98 he had voted to do away with the ground squirrel bounty of .01 cent for each tail turned in as a waste of good taxpayers money. He stated that 21, 687 tails was just a drop in the bucket compared to squirrels breeding far faster than they could be killed. This was used by the Wreckers as proof of his anti-farming bias. He was bad for farms and ranches. He had also voted against the purchase of all new walnut furniture for the Superior Courts office of Judge Venable, thus showing disrespect for the courts and law enforcement. He objected to the high rates set by the county for road sprinkling which no doubt cost him the vote of Martin Fly who sprinkled the dirt streets of Arroyo Grande including the road in front of Pat’s own house. He was in favor of the ban on the export of Pismo clams, Abalone, and Seals, the ordinance which he authored in 1892 which he said, “Will reduce their populations and show no advantage to our county.” He also was not in favor of the county building a road from Arroyo Grande to the Pozo district over the Santa Lucia mountain range which would only benefit the large ranches along it’s route, the cost to be paid by the counties taxpayers. All sensible but when has sensible ever entered political considerations.
Pat Moore, a Republican and staunch conservative always tended to be frugal with county monies. He didn’t believe taxpayers should be on the hook for the benefit of the wealthier citizens of the county. A perfect example was his almost always negative vote on propositions that the counties Roadmasters take over the many toll roads across the districts. The Cuesta Road was still a toll road and rather poorly maintained by it’s owners who petitioned the supervisors, asking that the county purchase it and relieved them of its maintenance because, they claimed, they couldn’t afford to do so themselves. “Nonsense, “He said, “they made a good profit from the most heavily traveled road in the county and did the least amount of work on it as they could get away with.” The completion of the Southern Pacific over the grade had cost them most of there freight traffic and they were desperate to unload it. They would certainly make a profit from any deal with the county. Supervisors were just as canny as politicians as they are today and ultimately bought the right of way which then operated as a financial loss to the county but grew the supervisors power base and individually cost them nothing, the burden being passed on to the taxpayer, most of whom would never even use the road. Spun properly this stamped Pat Moore as anti-progress and anti-business. It was to cost him his job.
The Honorable Patrick Moore, 4th district supervisor, Official Photo. San Luis Obispo County, 3 terms, 1890-1898, 1902-1906. Shannon Family photo.
Even the Herald, a paper run by Pat’s friend Stephen Clevenger could not afford to turn away advertising from the opposition which bought ads like the one below.
Arroyo Grande Herald:“Say! Have you seen the recommendations of J W Gilliam in the press? They present him as a “Clean Man.” Why don’t Pete Olohan and some other good Christian men take Pat Moore down to the creek and give him a good bath so he won’t be handicapped in the supervisorial race”.
Stephen Clevenger and Pat Moore were friends and Moore, an astute politician did not force Clevenger to take sides but instead ran his attacks on Gilliam in the Paso Robles Leader, the Cayucos Oracle and San Luis Breeze. He was shrewd politician and wanted no one to know where he stood.
Arroyo Grande Herald:“Say!There is some very wild guessing which way the election will go in Arroyo Grande. The Republicans claim the town by 82 majority and the Fusionists ( Democrats and Peoples Party) by over a hundred. They both claim to have the figures to prove it.”
Pat Moore was a well known patron of William Ryans saloon on Branch Street which was considered by the “Fusionist” party to be the nest in which the Republican vipers lived. It was his defacto office and where he held court and did his so-called shady deals along with his cronies Ryan, Corbit, Meherin, Beckett and the Rice brothers.
Arroyo Grande Herald: Yesterday rifle pellets were seen chasing a patron of Ryans Saloon as he scampered up Tabernacle Hill. Constable Whiteley has secured a horse and is in hot pursuit.
When the ballots were returned to the county courthouse to be counted, it was found that many clerks had not signed and certified the vote count, so Judge Venable locked the boxes up in his courtroom while his clerks re-counted them. The judge ruled that only his court clerks could do the counting, He said the Democrats were notoriously corrupt and could not be trusted. So the Democratic officials were given the boot. Perhaps not surprisingly, the Republican candidate Jim Gilliam walked away with the election and Pat Moore went home.
the Screechers and Wreckers next used their power as wealthy and influential landowners to lobby the clerks of the individual elementary school boards to withdraw from the Union High School district. All twelve schools did vote on this as each clerk had the individual power to do so. All the schools other than the town school had few students, Black Lake School polled just 21 boys and girls, most not landowners or in many cases, even US citizens. Enrollment lists show large numbers of names that could only be recent immigrants and unable to vote or even to read and write in English. Voting to withdraw by the various clerks of the boards must have been comparatively easy. The advantage to the clerk of each school was that they no longer would have to apportion some of their budget to support the high school. Only Arroyo Grande, Branch and Santa Manuela schools elected to stay.
The newspaper, referring to the opposition as rattlesnakes published figures showing that Newsom Springs school had paid in just $28.07 to the High School fund but received nearly $400.00 dollars from the county in recompense. Clevenger took this to mean that the schools themselves were not the main issue but the cost of taxation on the big ranch owners who made up less than 30% of the taxable acreage was. This made it a purely personal and selfish issue. He kept his paper hammering at them.
Arroyo Grande Herald:May 28th, 1898:Miss Edith Jatta and Miss Edith Carpenter went down to Nipomo yesterday after school on a visit to the first Edith’s sister, Mrs E. C. Loomis. They return in the morning.***
Francis Branch who started the first school in the valley for his children and those of his workers was more than fifteen years in his grave and his ranches had been deeded to his children who, in many cases married them out of the Branch family or failed as ranchers and sold the property to speculators and developers who had little connection to the land and the people on it. For example, The big Biddle ranch, once Branche’s Rancho Arroyo Grande and large portions of the Santa Manuela rancho were controlled by Judge Venable, he of the Walnut office furniture. He who we will hear from again.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:Some person with a can of poison for dogs has made a great success of his nocturnal adventures yesterday and quite a number of canines of more or less value, have turned their toes to the daisies.
After the by election to choose new clerks for the Board of Control and against all expectations, the “Wreckers” controlled six of the eleven seats on the district board. Bernard Miossi of the Sycamore Springs Ranch represented the Pismo school, “Bald” Willy Buck sat for Oak Park, Frank Newsom son of D F Newsom and founder of Newsom Springs school whose father had originally supported education and built the school. Frank didn’t like the fact that school taxes bit him in the pocketbook, Daniel Donovan from the lower Los Berros school district, Judge Venable from Santa Manuela school and James Beckett, a real estate speculator property owner and board member from Branch school figured they had the winning hand and set about the “Wrecking.” It was a case of the voters apparently not believing what was in plain sight as they still so often do and voting the way their bosses told them to do or not voting at all.
Arroyo Grande Herald:Mrs Robert English is expected home tonight fro San Francisco where she has been this week selecting her spring millinery.
San Luis Obispo Tribune: September 18th:School Tax Levy Fixed Yesterday. During the afternoon proceddings of the Board of Supervisors Budget allowances were set for the coming 1900 school year.
The only incident if note before the board was the matter of making an estimate to maintain the high school and over this the conflict raged merrily for hours.
Willis B. Buck of Oak Park and Bernardo Miossi, the former the president and the latter, the secretary of the board of control appeared before the board of supervisors and argued that the board should adopt the estimate of $ 775.00 made by a majority of the board of control to maintain the high school for the new school year.
Mister Orville Pence appeared on behalf of the citizens committee of the Arroyo Grande high school and demanded that the estimate be raised to something more than the previous years budget of $ 1,700.00. He stated that any reduction of the budget would make it impossible to keep the school open.
Willis Buck argued that there was little need for the school and that it was a needless burden on the taxpayers. Questioned on what the students were to do he stated they could attend school at the old Mission school or the parents could hire tutors. He said that eight students had already made plans to attend San Luis Obispo high school. When asked if this might be a financial burden on the parents he said he believed those that could afford to send their young people to San Luis Obispo would do so and those that could not were not really in need of any higher education.
There was much spirited back and forth but in the end the board sustained the estimate of the board of control and fixed the lower rate accordingly. The board was split 50-50 and chairman Gilliam cast the deciding vote.
The opponents of the Arroyo Grande Union High School won out. With the chairman of the Board of Supervisors, Mister Gilliam, elected from the Arroyo Grande district in 1998, voting to break the tie, it was ordered that the budget for the high school be reduced as requested by the board of control. The ousting of Pat Moore from his supervisors seat had its intended result.
With the budget firmly in hand, the high school board promptly voted in a pay schedule for principal, vice-principal and teachers. The principal, A F Parsons, the former county surveyor was to have his salary reduced by sixty eight percent. An article in the Santa Maria Times put it succinctly;
Santa Maria Times: September 11, 1898:The “Oppositionists” concocted a plan by which the high school will be stopped. They have fixed the salaries for the coming academic year, 1899-1900, as follows: Principal, $40 per month, Assistant, $25; Janitor$1; Rent for the school building per month, $5, and incidental expenses for the term, $2.50. Last school year the Principal received $125.00. The two high school teachers were reduced to $1, and $2, dollars a week. As it is now impossible to secure teachers at those salaries the “Wreckers” have made their point. The school will be unable to open in the fall of 1900.
San Luis Obispo Breeze:Many of the young ladies from Arroyo Grande have been visiting lately. San Luis Obispo may be a little dilatory in the way of street improvements but when it comes to pretty girls she is way up in the head of the procession. go down the street on any sunny afternoon and you will see more beautiful women to the square inch than any town in California. Up on the train today visiting our fair city were the misses Tootsie Lierley, Maggie Phoenix, Annie Gray, and Aggie Donovan. They were accompanied by Miss Edith Fesler of Santa Maria. (Teenagers all, 13 and 14 years old)***
Note: The cover photo of the young girls, top row L-R Annie “Nita” Gray, Margaret “Mamie” Tyler and Agnes “Aggie” Donovan. Bottom L-R “Tootsie” Lierley and Margaret “Maggie” Phoenix. Annie Gray was the authors grandmother. “Mamie” Tyler would become a teacher and teach in Western Washington in a log cabin school. Maggie would Marry Archie Harloe and teach nearly her entire career in the Arroyo Grande School District. Margaret Harloe elementary school is named for her.
*Doctor Charles Clark was affectionately known as the baby Doctor. He buzzed around the valley delivering children by day and night including my own aunt Mariel who was born at her parents home in Bee Canyon up in the Verde district in 1916.
*Missouri Eldridge was the niece of Pete Olohan, who was very likely another participant in the hanging.
*I’ve often wondered who their chaperone was. They wouldn’t have been allowed to go without one in 1900.
*The Misses Jatta and Carpenter’s fathers were well known members of the lynch party.
Arroyo Grande Oracle: The Arroyo Grande High School class of ’99 will have no commencement this year. Arrangements were being made for the affair and undoubtedly it would have been a grand affair and would certainly have obliterated much of the ill feeling towards the school by our neighbors who dominate the school’s board of control. Certain comments by students and faculty in the Herald caused the ceremony to be declared off by Willis Buck, chairman of the Board of Control. If the students and teachers are not willing to work to build up the school they cannot blame those who are prejudiced for trying to wreck the institution and cause disbandment of the High School district….
When I was a little guy I would sit at the kitchen table and listen to my parents talk. I wasn’t home schooled, I went to a regular school, a two room one nearly a century old but my real education came as I sat at that grey Formica table and listened to lessons from my parents and their friends. I don’t think they saw themselves as teachers but those little lessons have been rattling around in my head. I’ve been trying to catch up with that time all of my life.
My dad was a big teaser. He loved to tease his mother, my grandmother, who was easily embarrassed and would blush at the drop of a hat. He especially he liked to work on us, his three boys. Almost every thing he said had some little joke woven into it. Some play on words that he knew would confound us. Teach us too. What would you expect from a man who kept a very well thumbed World Almanac right on the kitchen table next to the salt and pepper.
Some of his talk made no sense to me. Such as, who was Leonard Rong and why was he the opposite of Leonard Wright. I heard right and wrong. No one explained this to me. They just tossed out names as they spoke with no explanation added. I’m sure mom and dad never thought twice about explaining who these people were, we were just little kids and didn’t know those men. I had seen Leonard Rong and he looked all right to me, nothing about him seemed wrong. When I asked why he was wrong, dad said, “Why he’s a man out standing in his fields.” What did standing in the field have to do with it. The little mind tried to fill in the gaps.
I mean, did “Dick Dock” have a real name or was the eponymous one just too good not to use. And how about George Arita? George, what Japanese man used the name George? I knew Kaz, Stone, Sab, Haruo and Aki, but George, it didn’t seem correct. There was no explanation for “Jinks” either, or “Ace,” “Bunny” “or “Arza.” Ace was a cool name, Arza seemed weird and what grown up is named Bunny. Seriously, we just though they were making a joke.
My dad sold some of his vegetables to a Mister Get in Los Angeles. I gathered that he was a Chinese man which confused me because I wasn’t sure whether Mister was Chinese or not, and did he go get something, was that his job, getting things. So confusing. Later on I went with my father to Mister Get’s home in Silverlake and had dinner with he and Mrs. Get. It was pressed duck. What! What did they mean pressed duck? Did they mean it was picked up off the highway or was it smashed by a heavy weight. Dad said it was cooked with a brick. How is that even possible. There was no telling.
What about “Coot?” I didn’t think that was real name for a person. I mean the little black ducks with yellow feet that swam in the Oceano lagoon were Coots, but a person. I didn’t think so but when I asked Pop about it he just laughed and said, “Silly Boy.”
My great aunt Anna lived in Santa Ana. Well, OK, but who was she and why was she ever mentioned? Dad said she was a spinster. A What? Was she good at spinning around, did she spin webs? Please explain. I saw her once, she was dumpy, another confusing word, had her hair tightly curled as maiden aunts did in 1955 and turned out to be a seriously vague person, at least to me. She wore a blue dress, pointy spectacles and sturdy shoes. There was no spinning.
We wondered why aunt Mickey was named after Mickey Mouse and my aunt June after the sixth month. Was she born then? Were grownups deliberately trying to confuse their children? Maybe it was a trick my aunt started so that we’d remember her birthday and get her a present.
My dad did not swear, or if he did he sure didn’t do it in front of us. He did have a few choice words he used though. Once he called a man a chiseler. I thought that meant he was a carpenter and built things but at the same time I knew the man sold groceries so how could he be chiseling? It just didn’t make any sense. Dad once called someone and S. B. in my hearing and being about six or seven, I said, “Daddy, whats an S.B.?” He explained that it meant the Silva Brothers, Manuel and Johnny who farmed next to us. When I mentioned it at school, Manny jr. took a swing at me which made it all the more confusing.
My uncle Jackie had some phrases he liked to use. He would say “It’s the Berries.” What in the world were the berries? Did he mean we were going to eat some or pick them, he never explained. How big was a bunch of malarkey? Was it something that needed to be counted or possibly weighed. I once heard him call someone a “Dumb Dora,” to which my dad replied, “She ain’t so dumb.” They both laughed at this. Was it some kind of secret code? We didn’t know. Made me feel like a “Dumb Cluck.”
My mom told dad that my cousin Brucie was a Holy Terror. I thought she meant he tore up hymn books or Bibles in church. Later on I learned from himself that he really was, he smashed my toy truck and hit me with the same stick for telling on him. Mom was right as she so often was.
Gobbledygook, Hodgepodge and flabbergasted were enough to make your head hurt. Parents could talk in a language that was almost foreign or maybe it was and children were not supposed to understand.
My aunt Eva talked to me about her dog Skipper and said that after Thanksgiving dinner she was going to walk him. What in the world did that mean? Every dog I knew could already walk. We never had any dogs that couldn’t. Matter of fact they almost always ran. From here to there and after the pickup, the tractors or they ran in circles around my dad when he was in the fields. Aunt Eva lived on Orange Street in Santa Maria which was the largest city I had ever seen so I assumed that strange goings on happened there which I knew nothing about. The street wasn’t orange either, it was grey colored, so, see what I mean?
My parents being silly. 1943. Shannon Family Photo
Then there was the cornbread. Cornbread was a staple of our diet in the fifties and I’d say all the kids liked it. My mom didn’t use recipes much, she cooked from scratch, another word that didn’t seem to make any sense but cornbread was easy and in lean years it might be the main course. The kids ate it with butter, my dad did too but my mother put it in a glass of milk, stirred it and ate it with a spoon. That seemed so strange to me, I mean, we were four against one when it came to eating it the right way I think. She said it was because she was from the south but like all confusion she wasn’t from the south, she was from California, born and raised. Her great grandparents were from Mississippi and came through Texas to Anaheim but that wasn’t her. She never traveled there. I just though that parents would naturally be on the same page. Boy was I wrong about that. And what exactly is the same page?
Another one; what’s a Mairzy Doat? It simply could not be explained. Dad said it was a song. Must be in a foreign language because I’d never seen either a Doat or a Mairzy. Maybe like a horse? I don’t know.
When my dad got a little transistor radio he told me that, “It was the greatest thing since sliced bread.” Come on Pop, everybody knows all bread is sliced. It comes in a blue and white checked plastic wrapper and its in pieces, nobody has to slice it. I knew he was pulling my leg then.
He once told me he drove out to the See Ranch and that it was out past Bunny’s on the way to Stony Creek. See the problem?
Was there no end to it? Please explain these things to me Dad. He said “I’ll do it when the cows come home, O K?”
He didn’t though, we lived in a time where children were seen but rarely heard. We would have to figure it all out ourselves. Maybe it would all be clear under the Blue Moon. I don’t know. I could be Rong.
Set the dial for late spring 1898, Arroyo Grande, San Luis Obispo County California. Deep in the center of the old Cow Counties.
We got our news from the local papers, the saloon, the cafe and the poker table. Wheels (Bicycles) are all the rage. It’s a small world in the Bloody Fourth. The fourth supervisors district had a well deserved bad reputation as does the rest of San Luis County. The last armed holdup of a stagecoach occurred on the Cuesta grade in 1888. Arroyo Grande men lynched a fifteen year old boy and his father in 1886. They left them hanging from the Pacific Coast Railroad bridge for all to see, including children on their way to school. The illegal lynchings far outnumbered the legal ones. (Just one legal ) Nearly the entire male population of Arroyo Grand had descended on its little Chinatown and sent the 25 residence running. They burned it to the ground. Saloons, Arroyo had eleven, were frequent scenes of gunplay. The town constable of Arroyo Grande was gunned down in the Capitol Saloon and the shooter got off on self-defense. Soiled Doves thrived in all of our the counties little towns and San Luis Obispo’s was reportedly first class. My great grandfather John Shannon still occasionally carried his Smith and Wesson .41, left over from his days as a Santa Clara County sheriffs deputy. My great, great uncle Patrick Moore, a native of Cavan, Ireland, sits in the fourth’s seat at the Board of Supervisors.
The Arroyo Grande Herald:publishes a report by the U S Navy recognizing the existence of Sea Serpents. We’re glad this vexatious matter is closed.
As it is, it has ever been. Styles change, Technology does too, people don’t. In 1900, San Luis Obispo counted over a hundred schools. Names like, Liberty, Banning, Freedom, Cienega, Nipomo, and Branch. There was Allaince and Eagle in Shandon, Edna and Freedom, York Mountain and La Paloma in the upper Los Berros Canyon. Each one served children who lived within short distances. Some had enrollments where almost every child had same the last name. Oak Park school was full of Patchetts, Nipomo sported Dana’s, some were filled with children of almost every ethic or immigrant group you could imagine. Most saw the importance of education for their children. Some citizens saw waste and fraud and were determined to set things “Right.”
Built at a cost of $ 793.50 by B F Stewart of Arroyo Grande. “26 x 40 feet and of a pretty design.” SLO County Schools photo.
It’s a drought year and warnings of reduced water use are rampant. In those days there were no dams or state water projects to take up the slack. Periodic droughts had devastated the cattle ranches over the previous two decades and led to the economy diversifying. Farming, particularly orchards and dairy had picked up the slack. Dried fruits shipped from Port Harford and dairy from Spooners landing on the Pecho Rancho were thriving business’s. Hopes for the Southern Pacific’s completion of its line between San Francisco and Los Angeles was rampant but “The Gap,” as it was referred to was still in the future. Freight could only travel by wagon north from tracks end at the tiny town of Surf in the Lompoc Valley.
TheEvening Breeze:County supervisors pass an ordinance restricting the harvest of Abalone in the north county.
The Spanish American War had begun on April 21st after the American battleship main blew itself up in Havana Cuba. The California National Guards Rangers, Company “G” was actively recruiting in the county. As usual Patriotic Fever was driving young men to sign up in order to go punish the dastardly Spaniards. “How dare they spit on our noble flag.” Thats an actual quote from our own Arroyo Grande Herald newspaper, the Democratic voice of our community. The Republican newspaper, the Recorder published by a local saloonkeeper and brick maker was equally strident. Peter”Pete” Olohan, what bartender was ever called Peter, was a very successful saloon keeper and ran the towns first brick kiln behind his business along Arroyo Grande creek. His bricks made from clay silt deposited on Tallyho creek just below Becketts lake. His bricks transformed the town as merchants quickly replaced many of the old western style buildings with new brick structures.
San Luis ObispoTribune:The news of Arroyo Grande states that a firewood famine is imminent. Most of the dry wood has been shipped to San Francisco and due to the over cutting of Oak trees, little will be available for winter.
Little Dean Polhemus gave five cents to build a new battleship Maine. 1898. His son would die at sea in WWII. Patriotism takes many forms. Shannon Family Photo
Every paper in the county was beating The Long Roll as hard as they could, war fever was everywhere. Flags and red, white and Blue bunting were on sale at Wardens store in San Luis and at Aron and Alexanders in Arroyo Grande.
The Arroyo Grande Recorder:The nefarious Spanish overlords of Cuba have used and infernal Device to blow up the battle ship Maine and school children are sending their pennies to build a new one.
Young men like Joe Bristol, George and Frank Dana, Joe Dominguez who, along with Ed and Burnett Knotts, a cafe owner from Nipomo drove up to the courthouse and took out enlistment papers. Shipping out for Cuba would end Nipomo’s superb local baseball team as the players, in a fever pitch for war made their way north to volunteer.
Arroyo Grande Herald:Mrs J.D. Skidmore grew a tremendous Strawberry more than ten inches in diameter.We think it would take a couple big bites.
A June 1998 notice in the Herald listed the names of the graduates from the Arroyo Grande Elementary School. Annie Grey and John “Jack” Shannon are among the eighth graders. My future grandparents. If you look at their birthdates, his being three years before hers, you might wonder why they are in the same class of graduates at all.
Arroyo Grande Elementary school. Annie Gray in all white, 1st row, . Jack Shannon 2nd from right back row.
If you are counting there are 27 girls and only six boys. Not uncommon for the time, education not being entirely necessary for boys and what did you do with a girl until she married and had children anyway?
My grandfather, like many boys at the time was considered grownup and able to do a mans work. He knew this. His parents did too. They owned an orchard and raced chickens for eggs and meat and 14 year old boys were essentially free labor. There is a family story that illustrates this to a tee. My grandfather once asked my father if he would rather go to church with mommy or stay home and milk cows with his father. He chose cows. He was eight. That was 1920. The idea still persisted that if you were old enough to do work; you did.
Arroyo Grande Recorder:Hunting season has opened and the boys are determined to make the Quail and Ducks less numerous.
My grandfather wasn’t resistant to education, after all my he sent my father to Cal, Class of 1934, it’s just that the times didn’t require that most men be able to do more than read, write and do arithmetic. “The lack of education didn’t hurt me none”.* Jack Shannon didn’t have the patience to read the law or be a professor of anything though he certainly could have. He just couldn’t sit still. Dad once said of him; “When your grandfather cut hay, he cut hay,” meaning he was all in on anything he did.
John William “Jack” Shannon about 1897. Shannon Family photo.
It wouldn’t have made any difference to him anyway because that same year the Arroyo Grande High School was savagely disenfranchised and closed and it looked like it was for good. San Luis Obispo High School had just recently barely survived the vote to close it. Education for children past fourteen was under attack.
San Luis Obispo Breeze: The board of Supervisors has voted to allow the purchase of a typewriter for the office of education.
Somehow the past always seems be much more idyllic than the present. Not as messy. A Norman Rockwell dream, a Horatio Alger, poor but noble boy pulling himself up by his bootstraps to run a railroad kind of story. Certainly not the Sinclair Lewis “Hey, lets go work in the Chicago slaughter houses” kind. Think of the plowboys wiping their brows, attached to the nether ends of horses, trudging through the fields for hours and days on end. You don’t need much education for that.
Boys from wealth should be educated because, after all, someone had to run the country. Working class kids were needed for other things. Hard rows needed hoeing.
Arroyo GrandeWeekly Herald:The citizens of Arroyo Grande have subscribed money to buy leg irons to be used on vagrants who refuse to move on. The miscreants will be sentenced to work at hard labor on the roads
The local newspapers tell the story. In the style of the late 19th and early 20th century features and opinion pieces chronicle the story of how all this destruction of education happened. In the snarky, joking writing style of the day in which papers didn’t try to hide their politics behind professed fairness, after all they needed advertising revenue to stay profitable and news was crafted to satisfy the politics of men. To wit; in Arroyo Grande there were two newspapers, The Herald, a Democratically inclined publishing house and The Recorder owned by brick maker and saloon keeper Pete Olohan a staunch Republican. From opposite ends of Branch Street they hurled barbs at each other, a distance of three blocks, the entire length of the little town. Both papers were read and discussed in the saloons and mens fraternal associations like the Odd Fellows and Masons. The talked in the dining houses and with other men leaning on their buggies of a Saturday morning as they waited for the little woman to do the shopping. Chewing on five cent cigars they tossed their opinions about like baseballs, some lobbed, some fired like bullets. If women had any opinions they weren’t listened to for it would still be a decade before they were able to vote. Political power was still out of reach unless it came from the kitchen or bedroom.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:Mrs M. T’ Runels of Nipomo made a hasty trip to north yesterday to attend to the affairs of her son, Harry T Talmadge who was crushed to death by the wheels of a train in the Santa Clara yards while making a hasty escape from the attendants of the St Agnew Insane Asylum.
It is an historical fact that the first state in the union which gave women the right to vote, Wyoming in 1869, believed that suffrage would attract women to move there. Men outnumbered women six to one at the time and it was exceedingly lonely out on the big ranches. That may be so but it should be noted that the wives of the state put their feet down; “Clem if you don’t vote for suffrage, its going to be a long, lean and very cold winter for you out here on the ranch.”
In fact it was the farm and ranch vote that put it over the top. The movers and shakers in the towns didn’t want women meddling in their affairs but they were beaten by ranchers wives. It would be another fifty years after Wyoming that the woman of Arroyo Grande were legally able to vote.
Arroyo Grande Oracle:Two young men named Scott and Foster were arrested yesterday and fined ten dollars each for using rough language to Mrs Donovan who was in her yard as they passed her house in Los Berros.The fine likely hurt less than the horsewhipping administered by the town constable.
So it was money that did the school in. The Cow Counties of Central California were still a farm and ranch economy. The days of the Rancheros was a decade or two in the past but many of the old Ranchos were still operating. New owners in the cattle, dairy or orchard business were being assessed by the school district in order to fund the schools. They didn’t like it. At fifteen dollars per hundred acres it was considered a terrible burden to carry and the whining and screeching was carried on in the papers of the day.
Several years of drought and crop failures had ranchers and farmers on edge. The thought that the county might raise taxes to support schools some though were useless set their teeth on edge. A ground swell to close down the Arroyo high school was growing with prominent men leading the charge. If a man was wealthy enough he could send his children to private high school in San Francisco or closer to home in San Luis Obispo’s Mission school. It wasn’t long before battle lines were clearly drawn.
“The Arroyo. Grande Herald noted in February 1898 that a petition has gone before School Superintendent Meese asking for a special election on the question of disincorporating the Arroyo Grande High School District. The law requires that a petition can only be signed by the heads of families but that many who signed the papers were were not. Many signatures were by men who, no women of course, were in favor of continuing the schools operation. It can be assumed that these men wish the matter brought to a vote and bring this vexing matter before the people of the district and settle the matter once and for all. A few ignorant screechers have been howling against the school for some time and would have succeeded in closing the high school if it wasn’t for the determined fight put up by the Herald last fall, the institution would not now be running. The opponents are proceeding in proper form this time and the Herald gladly accepts the gage of battle and will abide by the will of the people.“
The town of Arroyo Grande was a prosperous community and had a thriving downtown. Three blocks of businesses lined Branch Street where you could purchase almost everything you needed. The Pacific Coast narrow gauge railroad connected it to the harbor at Port Harfod, to San Luis Obispo and points south and east. Oil drilling, quarries and agricultural produce were its main cargo. A person could take a steamer from Port Harford to San Francisco which was California’s largest city. Los Angeles was still a dusty pueblo of no particular note. From the Southern Pacific railroads terminal at San Luis Obispo you could travel north to any place in the country you wished.
Arroyo Grande was a wooden, false fronted frontier town with more saloons than you could shake a stick at. There were small hotels, two hardware stores, a pair of blacksmiths and a bakery. At Aaron and Alexander’s store you could buy just about anything. Today it would be called a department store. The idea that you could do all your shopping in one place was still a novel idea in the little town.
Arroyo Grande Herald:A charge of battery is being held against two toughs for hitting a young Portuguese boy with their whip. There was not the slightest provocation for the offense.
Though the streets were still dirt with a sprinkling of gravel or covered with hay in the winter because the wet adobe soil was a thick as peanut butter and your buggy could sink up to its hubs after a rain storm. A water wagon patrolled the town in the summer sprinkling to keep the dust down. Most houses had running water supplied by the water companies who pumped it from the creek but most were without indoor bathrooms and the tin tub and outhouse were still behind nearly every house.
Martin Fly’s Arroyo Grande Water Wagon on Bridge St. Photographer unknown, about 1900
The highway to the south called the Nipomo Road, which began at Bridge Street was corduroyed with cottonwood logs and covered with gravel from the creek until it passed Supervisor Moore’s home which overlooked the east side of the valley. Not that many years before, most of the valley was an almost impenetrable marsh, dense with Encino and Alamo trees stitched together with wild blackberry. Horse nettle and the long branches of Poison Oak, it’s glossy dark green leaves inviting the unwary to touch. The Penstemon, Coyote Bush and Monkey Flower so thick that it was impassable for a horseman. The thick mass of vegetation was, until the 1860’s patrolled by the Grizzly Bear, Ursus Horribillus. (Horrible Bear) who might find you and your horse a tasty meal.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:John Barenburg jr. returned home last Saturday evening after an absence of over a year, during which time he has visited the Klondike and worked the mines of the frozen north. His friends are glad to see him again.
The valley was alive with a riot of color in the spring, with yellows, purples, red, dusty white and best of all the golden California Poppy. Don Francisco Branch and his 23 year old bride Manuela were stunned when they came over the low hill at the back of our ranch and first saw it in flower in late February of 1837.
The original maps of the three Ranchos on which Arroyo Grande was built were the Bolsa de Chamisal, Corral de Piedra and the Santa Manuela which all listed nearly the entire valley as a Cienega. The Cienega, or marshy bog had to be cleared for farming and at the turn of the century during the school crisis, the clearing was still incomplete. Remnants of this Cienega still remain along the upper Pismo lake preserve which is along North 4th Street today.
Cayucos Vigilent:The Swiss- Italian Hotel has been renamed the Cottage Hotel. It will be repainted and will soon look as pretty as the spring millenary.
When the county board of supervisors was formed and met for the first time on December 13,1852, the very first order of business was to form a county school system. The vote was unanimous with supervisors Francisco Branch, Captain William Dana, Joaquin Estrada and Samuel Adams Pollard all voting aye. The first three were rancheros holding considerable lands and Sam Pollard was married to Captain Dana’s daughter Maria Josefa Antonia Sirila. Though from widely distant places and having little to no formal education themselves they knew the value of schools and they meant to provide for a good education for their families. Initially children were taught in the home because the population was very small and distances between the isolated ranches was so great. The entire county population was just 360 souls though the census forms list only property owners, their families and servants. Rough and ready, the county was thick with bandidos, murderers and other criminals on the run from gold fields and cities and towns farther north. For years after establishing a school system few school houses were actually built. Isolated school houses weren’t safe for children for another decade until the trash had been taken out or hung up; by the neck.
San Luis Obispo Tribune:The Hon: C.H. Johnson has closed a deal with Ah Luis for all the brick owned by the latter at his kiln north of the city.The towns first mayor intends to build a magnificent two story building on Higuera Street at Chorro.
Arroyo Grande’s school district dated back to the famous Oak Tree school, the areas first. In 1860 a young man was hired to teach the children of the Rancheros. Don Francisco Branch who owned David Mallaghs old adobe house, which was on the hillside below Crown Hill, donated the house for the first school building in the valley. The decrepit old building, built in the 1840’s, was swept, rats, bats and owls expelled and resident raccoons and possum beat a hasty retreat down to the creek. Rough made furniture for desks and chairs were donated by the families who wanted their kids to be educated. Somehow a slate board was found and hung from a wall. Hitching posts were built for the children who came on horseback, for many lived more than walking distance away. When school was in session the old adobe was ringed about with horses and a buggy or two, horses chewing on corn from their feedbags or standing hipshot, dozing while they patiently waited for the kids.
The David Mallagh Adobe, 1880’s San Luis Historical Society photo
Thirty years later the town of Arroyo Grande had been established and was now ringed with one and two roomed grade schools. A one room school in upper Verde Canyon, A two room in the Oak Park district, Santa Manuela at the entrance to Lopez Canyon, a school in the upper Lopez, Branch school near the old Francisco Branch adobe; up the Huasna, a one room in Los Berros Canyon and La Cienega along the lower Arroyo Grande creek. Pismo and Oso Flaco schools rounded out the district. If there were enough children living within an eight or so mile diameter there was a school. Most residents saw a necessity in educating their children.
Arroyo Grande Herald:Aron and Alexander announce the Grand Midsummer Display in cotton dress goods. See the new Ebilenes, Eolines, Gaze de Soie, and Figured Lawns, Roidered Waist Patterns, Ladies and Children’s tan shoes and lace hosiery to match.Ask for prices.
Frank Newsom opened the first official school in district one and taught classes at the old mission. In a dusty room, children sat with chalk and slate on wooden benches made by the Indian neophytes for the padres, decades old. Newsom taught in Spanish with a little English thrown in because almost all the children were descendants of marriages between the Ranchero’s and their Californio wives. The occasional Indian child was almost always a Spanish speaker. There was no such thing as a textbook and reading material were limited to a few donated books. Any kind of book would have had to come by ship from the east coast so there weren’t many.
Old San Luis Obispo Mission in 1865. Photo: Calisphere
Born in Petersburg, Virginia, Newsom was all of 18 years old. He arrived in old San Luis Obispo and being a literate man and nearly penniless he gladly took the teaching job. Three years later he was teaching school at the Branch family’s Mallagh adobe just downhill from todays Paulding Middle School. In 1863 he married Francisco Branch’s daughter Anna and by 1870 was running a farming operation on the lands that had been deeded to his wife by her father. He established a small school there for his own children which eventually numbered eleven; poor Anna. He also taught the children of his neighbors. They were still taught in Spanish. In the 1880 census he listed himself as a hotel keeper because with the discovery of the hot sulphur springs in the upper Guayal canyon he had built a small hotel where people could come and “Take the waters.” No longer a poor man his politics had changed concerning schools, especially High Schools.
Newsom Springs school, Frank Newsom in the big hat. 1870’s. Historical Society Photo.
Newspapers began reporting in 1898 dissatisfaction with the high school. Bernardo Miossi, a farmer and rancher and owner of the Sycamore Springs ranch near Pismo Beach and a member of the board of control, school board in todays terms, who represented the Pismo Area, Frank Newsom, former pioneer teacher, Dan Donovan of the Los Berros district and Willis B Buck who farmed in the Oak Park section of south county were all vocally opposed to the continuation of the Arroyo Grande high school. “A waste of time and money,” Dan Donovan said, quoted in the Herald.
They were out to get rid of it, By hook or by crook. Very quickly, the gloves were off.
Arroyo Grande Herald:The board of Supervisors today granted 84 liquor licenses countywide. They expect to continue the review tomorrow as there are many more applications. At this place, License for Frank Babcock, Frank Cochran, Knotts brothers. E. Knotts, Bernardino Souza, and Peter Olohan. (2)**
Coming, Chapter two.
Arroyo Grande Herald: September 16, 1898.There are a number of citizens who are anxious on one ground or another that the educational facilities of the Arroyo Grande region should be continued….
(*Paul Simon, “Kodachrome”)
(**Arroyo Grande Valley Districts population, 1900 was 3,399. At the time it boasted over a dozen places to get a drink.)
Michael Shannon is a world citizen, teacher, and surfer. He attended a two room Grammar school himself. He write so his children will know where they came from.
Family relationships can be so hard to untangle even when you’re part of the family. Being a “Borrowed” child, Nita lived with her maternal aunt and uncle from the time she was eight. She moved up to Arroyo Grande in 1893 to live with Uncle Patrick Moore and his wife Sarah. After seven years there and at the age of fifteen, Nita saw her aunt Sarah die of Stomach Cancer. For much of the early 20th century, stomach cancer was the leading cause of cancer death in the United States, particularly amongst women. Heavily salted and smoked foods and the lack of refrigeration were thought to be the leading causes.
The San Luis Obispo Tribune wrote that, “The sad news reached this city yesterday of the death of Mrs. Patrick Moore, wife of Supervisor Moore, in San Francisco where she went from her home in Arroyo Grande for treatment of cancer of the stomach. She was a good woman and her death will be mourned by many.” *
Nita was just about to enter high school. At fourteen it was a tragedy for her and though Sarah was not her mother she ran a very close second. Nita had come live with the Moores when she was about to turn eight, just at the age where serious long lasting memory begins. Nita knew her mother Jeannie Grey well enough and saw her family regularly, but her daily life marched to Sarah Moore’s heartbeat.
Sarah Moore, left, with Annie “Nita” Grey in the white shirtwaist 1899. Shannon Family Photo
As the big house was always full of her friends and the family servants she stayed with uncle Pat rather than returning home to the ranch in Santa Maria with her parents, brothers and sisters. Part of the families agreement was that Nita be educated and receive a substantial property upon Pat Moore’s passing.
Just two years later Uncle Patrick remarried. He chose a popular local schoolteacher, Miss Mollie O’Conner. The papers made a great joke about this by slyly stating that it was a May December romance and it may have been though in family lore the they were happy together.
The following is from the Salinas Index of July 15, 1903. “It needs no particular explanation to residents of SLO County except that perhaps some would like to know why the genial supervisor did not face the music at home instead of going away to Salinas to get married. “Today at 10 o’clock Judge J H Brown performed a marriage ceremony which united the hearts and lives of Patrick R Moore of Arroyo Grande and Mary “Mollie” O’Conner of Washington. The ceremony was performed in the parlors of the Abbott house and the host and John Lavery and were witnesses to the ceremony.“
“The groom is a prominent resident and supervisor of SLO county and the bride is a schoolteacher. Although well advanced in years at 73, the happy couple boarded yesterday’s southbound train with a happy smile and sprightly step of a couple who might have been just old enough to procure a license. Mollie “O” was all of 42.“
Annie “Nita” Grey, Patrick Moore and Mollie “O” 1904. Shannon Family Photo
Nita had lived her entire life except for the four years in Berkeley and she was very familiar with the beauty of the sand of Pismo Beach. Smooth, satiny; fine as snow drifts turned to gold, carved into wavelets by the wind racing in from the Pacific, polishing each grain to a satiny sheen. The gently rolling hills dusted with yellow mustard and dense clumps of coastal sage, called Chamiso by the Spaniards, covered the north slopes. Dotted on the south and west by groves of ancient Oak trees, this was the land she grew up in. It was the land of Ramona, Zorro, Jacquin Murrieta and was not long ago the pride of the Rancheros; Californios whose Vaqueros rode the slopes and canyons moving the cattle which formed the backbone of their economy. Their heyday just a decade before her birth. She was born on Rancho Guadalupe, she grew up on the old Bolsa de Chamisal Rancho of Francisco Quijada, a large portion of which was then owned by Patrick Moore her maternal uncle in whose home she was raised. She would spent most of her life right there, just a stones throw from the house she grew up in.
In a letter to her childhood friend Mamie, she wrote of her excitement at graduation and the extraordinary gift that Mollie “O” had planned for her. Nita and three of her friends were going to go up to the Yosemite Valley, a place she knew was completely unlike her home in San Luis Obispo county. She was to see the National Park which had just been designated as such by President Teddy Roosevelt four years earlier.
They all went down to the depot and took the Southern Pacific passenger train down to Merced. As early as 1908, the city of Merced, California adopted “Gateway to Yosemite” as its tourism slogan. It was a time when a trip from the coast to the Sierra Nevada took days instead of hours.
It was a nine hour trip because the train was what was known as a local. That meant it stopped at every town on the way. From Oakland, the old phrase “You can’t get there from here” was close to being true. They took the train south to Niles where they changed cars to head east on a spur through Livermore and Tracy to Lathrop and changed again to the local heading down through Turlock, Modesto the Merced where they would detrain again, wait for their luggage to be transferred, and there was a pile of that. Well off women did not travel lightly in 1908. They would need to dress for dinner at the hotels which required fine clothes and all the trimmings which would be unsuitable for adventuring. They packed dresses and sensible low heels. The hiking clothes would have been light canvas or sturdy cotton duck to combat the shrubbery, trees and the ever present dust. The dust, or duff as it’s called is everywhere when the weather was dry. Straw hats, kerchiefs and a vail to keep the insects away. And gloves, certainly, to keep delicate hands free from stickers and nettles.
Merced Depot, Nita in the light colored straw hat. Excitement on her face. 1908 Shannon Family Photo.
They stepped down from the cars and had supper at the cafe in the depot while the suitcases and trunks were unloaded and then placed in the baggage car of the short line Yosemite Valley Railroad for the trip up to El Portal where they would spend the night. The little train pulled out of the depot at 2 pm headed up the tracks for the eighty mile trip to tracks end at El Portal. She waddled along at about twenty miles an hour and made fourteen stops along the way arriving at the end of the line around 6 pm.
Del Portal Hotel, El Portal CA. Terminus, Yosemite Valley Railroad at the gateway to Yosemite. NPS Photo
Hotel Del Portal was one of the early first-class hotels established by the Yosemite Valley Railroad to accommodate passengers coming up from Merced to the terminus at El Portal, California, just outside of Yosemite National Park. The hotel set the standard for elegance in the Yosemite area. A trip up to the park was expensive and the formal hotels were built to serve those with the means to come and tour the valley.
The four-story Hotel Del Portal at the eastern terminus attracted celebrities and politicians alike, including William Randolph Hearst of the newspaper game. J.B. Duke head of the American Tobacco Company who introduced “Taylor Made” cigarettes in the 1880’s was one of the wealthiest men in America. Introducing what were originally called pre-rolled cigarettes in the late 1880’s made him. Strangely enough “Taylor Mades” reduced the use of plug or chaw tobacco and the constant spitting it required and is credited with a vast reduction in the transmission of Tuberculosis a disease which is airborne. People could now swap one form of death for another.
Another frequent traveler was John Muir. Muir spent as much time in the park as possible. In 1903, President Theodore Roosevelt visited Yosemite. He was guided by the naturalist. Roosevelt came up to the Wawona Hotel by stage. Rather than checking in to the elegant new hotel he insisted on camping under the “Grizzly Giant” Redwood tree where he slept comfortably on a pile of forty wool blankets. The two men spent three memorable nights camping, first under the outstretched arms of the Grizzly Giant in the Mariposa Grove of Giant Sequoias, then in a snowstorm atop five feet of snow near Sentinel Dome, and finally in a meadow near the base of Bridal Veil Fall. Their conversations and shared joy with the beauty and magnificence of Yosemite led Roosevelt to expand federal protection of Yosemite, and it inspired him to sign into existence five national parks, 18 national monuments, 55 national bird sanctuaries and wildlife refuges, and 150 national forests. Muir’s guided tour for Theodore Roosevelt was the catalysts for the president to declare the valley a National Park in 1906.
President Teddy Roosevelt and party standing at the base of the Grizzly Giant tree in the Mariposa Grove of Giant Sequoias, Yosemite, 1903. Left to right, two secret service agents; William H. Moody, Secretary of Navy; George Pardee, California Governor; Teddy Roosevelt, U.S. President; Dr. Presley N. Rixey, Surgeon General; John Muir; Nicholas Murray Butler, President Columbia University; William Loeb, Jr., Private Secretary; Benjamin Ide Wheeler, President University of California. Photo Joseph LeConte, Collection of the San Joaquin Library system, Mariposa Library
Muir declared in an article in the Sacramento Record-Union in 1876 “In God’s First Temples: How Shall We Preserve Our Forests?” The articles he wrote began to draw attention to the destruction of California forests. Muir who had worked as a cattle herder in the valley and later the sawmill at the base of Yosemite Falls was a first hand witness to the evolution from wilderness to exploitation at any cost.
Roosevelt himself wrote that, “It is vandalism to wantonly destroy or to permit the destruction of what is beautiful in nature, whether it be a cliff, a forest, or a species of mammal or bird. Here in the United States we turn our rivers and streams into sewers and dumping-grounds, we pollute the air, we destroy forests, and exterminate fishes, birds and mammals — not to speak of vulgarizing charming landscapes with hideous advertisements. But at last it looks as if our people are awakening.” or so he wished. More than one hundred years have passed and if my grandmother was here to read the news she would say that little has changed.
Nita and her California University friends were unwitting witnesses to the almost total destruction of the Oaks that gave Oakland its name. The original Ranchero family, the Peraltas referred to the area as “”El Encinal” for its dense stand of California live oaks which are the dominant tree of the coast live oak woodland habitat.This was translated more loosely as “Oakland” in the subsequent naming of the town, as recounted by Horace Carpentier in his first address as mayor: “The chief ornament and attraction of this city consists, doubtless, in the magnificent grove of evergreen oaks which covers its present site and from which it takes both its former name of ‘Encinal’ and its present one of ‘Oakland.” By Nitas time the forest had been completely logged off, as was the five square mile Redwood grove, once considered as most dense in the state, which had occupied the area which was now the Berkeley campus.
Nita, Mollie “O” and Blanche were part of a constant parade of well known and wealthy people who could arrive at the entrance of the valley by train instead of the twelve to fourteen hour stagecoach ride up from Merced as had been done until the previous year. The coaches were taken out of service in 1907 when the Yosemite ran its first trains to the edge of the park.
The following morning Nita breakfasted at the Del Portal and then saw her luggage loaded aboard the coach which would take her party up through the entrance to the park and the Sentinel Hotel where they would stay. After the turn of the century, The Sentinel was the only operating hotel in the valley. Because it was not winterized it remained closed during the winter season and only operated during summer.. This made little difference since the valleys total attendance was fairly low somewhere between two and five thousand a year before the railroad opened in 1907. The Yosemite RR made the trip up much easier. After the railroad arrived, along with the opening of the Del Portal Hotel, visitor numbers grew significantly . From 1908 to 1909 attendance grew to over 13,000, a leap of 5,000 from the year before. It doubled in attendance in 1915 to over 33,000 . Numbers would rise dramatically when automobiles were first let into the park beginning in 1913. In 1919 at the end of The Great War attendance jumped to over 58,000. Last year, 2022 the number was over 3.5 million.
Nita saw the park in the last days before automobiles, high numbers of people and a proliferation of new hotels, camps, paved roads, restaurants and visitor centers began the clogging the valley floor.
Risng earlyNita and her party took breakfast and then watched the loading of their luggage in the boot of the Mahta Wagon on which they would travel the rest of the way to the valley.
Manufactured in Merced, the Mahta was an 11-passenger stagecoach. Manufactured by Schofield & Alvord, it was a type of coach known as a Mud Wagon. Lighter than a Concord coach which is the coach featured in western movies, the Mud Wagon was the most common stagecoach seen in California. The Mahta was specifically designed for the Yosemite run. With comfortable upholstered seats it made several daily trips between El Portal and the valley. The road along the river was fairly level and the seventeen mile trip could be made in a day.
With picnic lunches supplied by the hotel, Blanche, Molly “O” and Nita settled into their seats excited by the day to come. They had dressed for the trip in sturdy side button shoes and skirts made of duck designed for the outdoors. Bonnets secured by hat pins and veiled against the dust and flies they laughed with anticipation as the coachmen shook the ribbons and clicked his tongue to set the four horse team in motion.
Traditionally coachmen who drove the California stages were called whips, and some, Jehu’s. In the Bible, it is noted of King Jehu that “he drives furiously” (II Kings 9:20). In the 17th century, English speakers began using jehu as a generic term meaning “coachman” or, specifically, “a fast or reckless coachman.” California had its share too. Charley Parkhurst known as “Six Horse” or one eye, for he’d lost his left eye to a horses hoof, drove his stage horses hard and like Hank Monk’s drive with Horace Greeley across the Sierra on the old Overland stage which was chronicled in Mark Twain’s “Roughing It.” For Sam Clemens, that was Twains real name, wrote, “I can tell you a most laughable thing indeed, if you would like to listen to it. Horace Greeley went over this road once. When he was leaving Carson City he told the driver, Hank Monk, that he had an engagement to lecture in Placerville, and was very anxious to go through quick. Hank Monk cracked his whip and started off at an awful pace. The coach bounced up and down in such a terrific way that it jolted the buttons all off of Horace’s coat, and finally shot his head clean through the roof of the stage, and then he yelled at Hank Monk and begged him to go easier–said he warn’t in as much of a hurry as he was awhile ago. But Hank Monk said, ‘Keep your seat, Horace, and I’ll get you there on time!’–and you bet, you bet you he did, too, what was left of him!”
By Nita’s time coaches no longer carried the mail or Wells Fargo strongboxes. The last stage robbers were long gone as were the Jehu’s. Her coach traveled at a sedate pace, bumping and rattling up the road. Any jostling was done by the seat-mates craning their necks to see the increasingly spectacular scenery as the canyon cut by the Merced River, which they were following began to narrow, nearly sheer cliffs rising high above them.
Stepping down from the mud wagon, the party took a quick lunch break sitting on fallen logs with the rivers chuckling in the background. The scent of pines filled the air, so different than the smells and sounds of the city of Oakland. Boarding the coach and settling down they continued towards Arch Rock, the entry to the valley. Two huge granite boulders had tumbled down and formed an arch through which the road traveled. A quick photo stop and then they moved on. The very tall trees closing in on the road created a vibrant green tunnel dappled by sunlight.
They traveled the road for a couple of miles when suddenly after a slight turn to the right, in an opening directly ahead, Bridal Veil Falls appeared as if by magic. Falling in a graceful sweep and wreathed by sunlight and sprays of water, it took their breath away. The gasps of his passengers caused the driver to smile, he himself felt the same awe each day as he entered the valley.
Soon the valley began to open up and on their left, El Capitan rose nearly a mile and one half straight up, towering over the valley, it sent a shiver of dread through the women. None of them had ever experienced anything like it. Off in the distance, Half Dome, rose more than a thousand feet higher than El Capitan. Nestled in the valley below sat the Sentinel Hotel, their destination.
The Sentinel Hotel and the Merced River. Library of Congress
The stage pulled to a stop in front of the verandah, the driver stepped down and helped the ladies alight. He then opened the boot for the bell boys to begin hauling luggage up the steps and into the hotel. Molly “O” was excited because she had a surprise for the girls, she had reserved the most spectacular room in the hotel for the princely sum of $ 5.00 a night.
The Big Tree Room, Sentinel Hotel postcard addressed to Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Grey, Nita’s parents. Shannon Family Collection.
The room was built around a 175 foot Incense Cedar tree. Not a piece of a dead tree but a live one. When they settled down after dinner the smell of cedar lulled them off to sleep.
When they came in to breakfast they saw on the wall of the dining room the famous photo of two girls standing on the overhanging rock at Glacier Point. They stopped to take a closer look and were thrilled that they would be going there to see it for themselves.
Miss Kittie Tatsch, a maid and for a time head waitress at the Sentinel hotel in the late 1890s and early 1900s, obviously a young woman with a cool head and; apparently, entirely destitute of nerves went up to Glacier Point and did a high kick on this perilous perch with her friend Katherine Hazelston. Dressed in long wide skirts identifying them clearly as women, they danced and did high kicks at Overhanging Rock, 3,000 feet above the Valley floor at Glacier Point The photo known as the two Kitties was on sale at the hotel when Nita arrived. She could look up from the verandah and see the point high above her. She was eager to go and see it for herself. She wondered, did she want to go out on the Rock? Would she?
The Two Kitties on Glacier Point. Photo: George Fiske, Collection, Library of Congress
The Four Mile Trail, linked Yosemite Valley to McCauley’s Mountain House at Glacier Point. Helen Hunt Jackson, author of “A Century of Dishonor” (1881) which chronicled the injustices perpetrated against American Indians, described the trail as “broad, smooth, and well protected on the outer edge, at all the dangerous places, by large rocks forming a low wall. Although it is the steepest trail out of the Valley, zigzagging back and forth on a sheer granite wall, one rides up it with little alarm or giddiness, and with such a sense of gratitude to the builder that the one dollar toll seems much too small.”
All aboard for Glacier Point. Library of Congress
The coach left the Sentinel, everyone aboard anticipating an adventure. Turning left onto the Glacier Point road the passengers were aware that on one hand the granite cliffs rose almost vertically and dropped off into sheer cliff on the other. Helen Hunt Jackson’s description of the road notwithstanding, The women shared a little alarm and a lot of giddiness. Nita knew they were safe and she shared later that the quakes and fears were simply delicious. Soon enough the coach rolled onto the granite terrace behind the point and came to a stop. Stepping down, the whip pointed out the way to Overhanging Rock and they walked toward it.
As they neared the edge they began craning their necks and had begun to sidle like crabs as the drop off neared. Chins up and weight on the back foot they stopped at the base of the rock trying to see without leaning too far over. It was a long, long way down. Finally by clustering together and screwing up their courage they they began to sidle sideways out onto the rock, not daring to lift their feet, carefully sliding their feet until they finally got as far as they could bear and holding hands for balance, they sat down. They felt so brave. And why not.
Blanche, Nita and Molly “O” on Overhanging Rock, Glacier Point. June 1908. Shannon Family Photo
The next three days were spent walking about and exploring. Mirror lake was astonishing in the morning light when it lived up to it’s name and reflected both North Dome and Half Dome in its polished surface.
They walked across the Merced River on the old log bridge holding onto the single handrail as the river, still running high in early June speckled their clothes with droplets of water come from the highest ridges of the Sierra where the ice never melted.
Yosemite Falls was magnificent, tons of numbingly cold water pitched from the ledge at the top and falling in waves of lace shimmering in the midday sunlight, rainbows dancing in and about like a kaleidoscope.
Molly “O,” Nita and Blanche, Merced River crossing June 1908. Shannon Family Photo.
When they returned to Berkeley Nita rejoined her husband Jack whom she had married in April, just six weeks before graduation. They moved into their home at 1927 Dwight Way, just off campus. The singular adventure of University life and her trip to Yosemite were the capstone of her single life. As was common, then, she surrendered half her life to her husband and just ten months later to her first born, my uncle Jackie, she gave up the other half. As my father was wont to say, a first class education and the opportunities it brought, limited as they were for a late Victorian girl were set aside and a long life as a housewife began. She put her memories away in a white cardboard box kept in the cupboard for the rest of her life. Nita became Annie Gray Shannon again.
She was born 75 years too soon.
A bemused Annie “Nita” Shannon and her new husband, April 10th, 1908 in the pretend car. Shannon Family Photo
Epilogue:
Yosemite is a place the family has returned too again and again. It has a mystic power that causes the mind to soar. As children we stayed at camp Curry and walked out into the meadow, sat on the grass and saw the Fire Fall. We marveled at mirror lake and inched closer to the edge of Glacier Point just as our grandmother had. I held my mothers hand to peek over the edge. So delicious for a kid. My wife and I honeymooned there in the old Ahwahnee. We’ve been to the old LaConte Lodge which is now a museum and skied the pass in winter. We’ve been to the chapel where the first non-denominational services were held in 1879. We introduced our own children to its wonders. Such a marvelous place.
Grandmother and grandson at the Le Conte Lodge, 1908 and 2019
Many, many years later I found this little card in a box of my grandmothers things. The photos and postcards and letters all together tell the story. The fact that she kept these things for her entire life, moving them from home to home gives them a special significance. The are the foundation of this story.
Michael Shannon is a World Citizen, Surfer, Teacher and a writer. He writes so his children will remember the good family they come from.
I know this to be true. Have you ever heard a truth, not shaded, parsed, paraphrased, but something that you know is clearly, purely, a truth? They’re rare, to be cherished and recalled time and again. Something heard which is clear and polished to brightness; something so clear as to be marveled at, precisely because they are so rare.
Lou Gehrig:
A tall man. Sloped shoulders, a baseball uniform of grey wool; pinstriped, his cap held before him as if in prayer, lifts his head and steps to the microphone planted on an impossibly green, manicured grass field, lowers his head and says softly, “Today, I consider myself the luckiest man on the face of the earth.” Despite his wonderful achievements as a Yankee first baseman, he will forever be remembered by the thing that killed him, “Lou Gehrigs Disease.” On June 2nd, 1941, Lou Gehrig died of ALS, still believing himself to be that lucky man. A truth.
The Brothers Van Gogh:
Theodorus loved his brother so much. They were, the two sides of the same coin. One successful, one not, one driven by ambition, one with none. Theo, self confident, the other without. Different worlds entirely but connected by brotherly love. One supported the other and was paid in useless paintings. Vincent wrote on the day he took his own life,
“Well, my work to me, I risk my life on it, and my reason has half foundered – all right – but you are not one of those dealers in men, as far as I know, and you can take sides, I find, truly acting with humanity, but what is the use?
Vincent Van Gogh had one human thing, a brother who loved him. A truth.
Captain Henry T. Waskow:“
‘This one is Captain Waskow,’” one of them said quietly.
“Two men unleashed his body from the mule and lifted it off and laid it in the shadow beside the stone wall. Other men took the other bodies off. Finally, there were five lying end to end in a long row. You don’t cover up dead men in the combat zones. They just lie there in the shadows until someone comes after them.
“The unburdened mules moved off to their olive grove. The men in the road seemed reluctant to leave. They stood around, and gradually I could sense them moving, one by one, close to Captain Waskow’s body. Not so much to look, I think, as to say something in finality to him and to themselves. I stood close by and I could hear.”
“One soldier came and looked down, and he said out loud, ‘God…damn, it!’
“That’s all he said, and then he walked away.
“Another one came, and he said, ‘God damn it to hell anyway!’ He looked down for a few last moments and then turned and left.
“Another man came. I think he was an officer. It was hard to tell officers from men in the dim light, for everybody was bearded and grimy. The man looked down into the dead captain’s face and then spoke directly to him, as though he were alive, ‘I’m sorry, old man.’
“Then a soldier came and stood beside the officer and bent over, and he too spoke to his dead captain, not in a whisper but awfully tenderly, and he said, ‘I sure am sorry, sir.’
“Then the first man squatted down, and he reached down and took the captain’s hand, and he sat there for a full five minutes holding the dead hand in his own and looking intently into the dead face. And he never uttered a sound all the time he sat there.
“Finally he put the hand down. He reached over and gently straightened the points of the captain’s shirt collar, and then he sort of rearranged the tattered edges of the uniform around the wound, and then he got up and walked away down the road in the moonlight, all alone.”*
Written on the field at the Battle of San Pietro during the Italian campaign in December, 1943 by Ernie Pyle, war correspondent. A Truth.
Barbara Shannon:
“Life is but a breath,” the Good Book says, and that is surely true. In the end, if you count money, houses and land, then she was poor. But if you count wealth as the love and affection of your family and friends then she was rich beyond counting.
She loved her husband, she loved her sons, she loved her son’s wives as the daughters she never had, and her grandchildren were the crown she wore in her old age.
Suddenly one day, she was used up and worn out and just as suddenly gone from our lives. Mom was not born in this valley, but for over fifty years this is where she lived and moved and had her being and here is where she died.
It is not such a sad thing really, to contemplate her laid to rest in our green and peaceful cemetery in the midst of her friends, neighbors and family whom she loved and who loved her. It is not such a sad thing, perhaps, to think of her lying in the shadows of the everlasting hills of this green and golden valley that we love so well.
The first time dad went to see her in the hospital, she was in a coma and was terribly ravaged by that awful, awful disease. When he walked into the room and saw her he said,
“No Mike, thats not my wife. Barbara is beautiful. I don’t want to remember her like this. Please take me home son.”
Now dad lies beside her, as one day, her sons will too. A truth.
Ray and Mariel Long
He was a cowman, she was an oilfield girl. They were two of the most naturally funny people I have ever known. They lived in an ancient ranch house in Watt’s Valley California. The house was so old it resembled an old drunk leaning on a lamp post. Only faith held it up.**
In the summers of the fifties it was overrun with their kids and heaps of cousins who came up to the ranch for the summer. There were horses, dogs, chickens, turkeys and cattle. There were kitties in the barn where the milking was done. In the early ‘morn they had little beards of milk, uncle Ray was partial to cats you know.
He saddled every kid with a nickname. He spared not one of us. There was Jughead, Festus, Shebang, Jeb and knothead. My mom was “Sis.” He meant nothin’ by it except to say he loved us and we knew it.
Mariel, our aunt Mickie was no kind of cook, her mother turned her nose up at the housewife life and her girls were on their own growing up. Uncle Ray rustled the big old iron stove in the corner of the kitchen. Dough God biscuits, tall and flaked, rashers of bacon and fresh eggs gathered that morning. The kids set at the long table with the oilcloth cover devoured his breakfasts washed down with fresh milk, pored from an old tin pitcher. That’s fresh milk straight from the cow, gobs of yellow cream floating on top with an occasional dead fly as a garnish. No one was afraid of fresh cream then, still warm from the cow, no.
It’s hotter than Hades up there come summer and each morning the kids would suit up and walk down in the pasture to the little dam where the water was about a foot deep. We would pretend twe could swim, occasionally rising out to lie on the grass pasture to dry off in the dappled sunlight poking through the willow leaves. We ate sandwiches made with wonder bread, mustard and baloney, store bought sugar cookies and dreamed of growing up to be cowboys.
Like uncle Ray.
Ray Clarence Long with his firstborn, my cousin Bruce, better known as Jughead. Shannon Family photo.
He rode the Sierra his whole life long. Pushing cattle up to the high meadows in the spring, bringing them down in the fall. He worked the stockyards in the valley when times were lean; which was almost always. Dad said he knew every trail, crick, and cow camp from Mexico to Oregon and I never doubted it. There is a scene in the book Monte Walsh where the Stud Duck turns to his friend when they see a puncher ridin’ their way and says. “That’s Monte Walsh, nobody sits a horse like Monte Walsh.” He might as well have been talking about my uncle Ray.
Ray Long up on Charm, Watts Valley 1952. Shannon Family Photo.
He hand rolled his smokes with the one hand and drank his bourbon straight. He was honest as the day is long and the good God has surely made no one like him since. He rode horseback ’til the day he died.
A Truth.
*Ernie Pyle seldom wrote about generals, he wrote about the ordinary people he cared for, the dirty shirt dollar sixty a day Dogface who marched from Tunisia to Germany.
**Surprisingly, that old house still stands under the Sycamore trees some some seventy years gone.
Micheal Shannon is a World Citizen, Surfer, teacher and writer. He writes so his kids will know their story..
Graduation came in May of 1908. After four years of study, the death of her uncle Patrick Moore in 1905 and the following year the great San Francisco Earthquake, Nita walked onto the stage at the Greek theater, accepted her diploma from Benjamin Ide Wheele
Commencement week, a round of celebrations, fraternity and club open houses, receptions and Class Day concluded on Wednesday with graduation. Faculty, regents, honored guests and alumni met at North Hall and the Library.led the graduating class up to the Greek Theatre. Dressed in their finest, the boys in high starched collars, the girls in their finest formal gowns. Their chin high lace collars stitched with traceries done by hand with initials worked as was Nita’s. The silk and chiffon fabrics used for the long narrow skirt ended three or four inches above the waist line and was held by a belt of stiff Petersham Cotton tied with a large bow in the back. The girls wore their hair up in the style of the Gibson Girl. Rolled and fluffed held by pins exposing the neck, the style was considered the height of elegance for young women.
The Gibson Girl had an exaggerated S-curve torso shape achieved by wearing a swan-bill corset. Images of her epitomized the late 19th- and early 20th-century Western preoccupation with youthful features and ephemeral beauty. Her neck was thin and her hair piled high upon her head in the contemporary bouffant, pompadour, and chignon, the “waterfall of curls” fashion. The statuesque, narrow-waisted ideal feminine figure was portrayed as being at ease and stylish.
The illustrator Charle Dana Gibson is credited for popularizing the standard look of the girl. Many women posed for Gibson Girl-style illustrations, including Gibson’s wife, Irene Langhorne, who may have been the original model. Irene was a sister of Viscountess Nancy (Langhorne) Astor. Mrs Astor besides being the first female member of Britain’s parliament was equally famous for her sharp tongue and took great pleasure in skewering Winston Churchill with it on every possible occasion. During a dinner party she informed Churchill that, “If you were my husband I would poison you,” to which he replied, “If you did madam, I would take it”. He could give as good as he got.
The Langhorne girls were immensely rich and two bought husbands with titles, Viscount Lord Waldorf Astor son of the richest man in the world at the time and Robert, the first Baron Brand. Wealthy American girls who married poor but titled Englishmen were titled by the American press as the “Dollar Princesses.”
The most famous Gibson Girl was probably the American-British stage actress, Camille Clifford, whose high coiffure and long, elegant gowns that wrapped around her hourglass figure and tightly corseted wasp waist defined the style. Miss Clifford also made popular the oversize woman’s hat known at the “Merry Widow.”
Irene Langhorne Gibson. The Original Gibson Girl. Public Domain print.
In Gibson’s drawings there was no hint at pushing the boundaries of women’s roles; instead they often cemented the long-standing beliefs held by many from the old social orders, rarely depicting the Gibson Girl as taking part in any activity that could be seen as out of the ordinary for a woman.
Nita and her friends certainly were aware of these trendsetters as any young woman of today would be. Women’s magazines, films and books held them up as ideals and in the old family photos of her at this time of her life she epitomized the look. Popular culture was alive and well in 1908, even in tiny Arroyo Grande where she was from.
Nita always seemed to me a serious woman but once she explained to me why she had a thoroughly beat up plug hat hanging on the hatrack in her office. You see, it was the fancy of students who attended the University of California, Berkeley at the dawning of the twentieth century to wear them. Upperclassmen and women, of which my grandmother was one, wore the old beaten up hats as a fashion accessory, much as my father wore his beanie when he was a student at Cal in the 1930’s. They must have found them on trash heaps or second hand stores, useless to anyone but college students who delight in being contrarians. My grandmother and her friends would walk around campus, from the North Hall to the Bacon Library Hall, or gather at the Charter Oak, dressed in the style of 1908, wearing shirtwaists, high collars and long dresses over high button shoes. The stately look we imagine today as being their nature. It’s too easy to forget that they were twenty year old girls. Just as they are in college today, full of high spirits and dreams of a life yet to be lived.
Photo, Calisphere
Each senior draped in a blue university gown, the mortar board with its golden tassel swaying in time with the march as they made their way to their seats for the ceremony. The sound of sibilant silk and cotton dresses, the soft clack of shoes on pavement accompanied the students like an orchestra. In the gentle breeze coming up from the bay, the mingled scents of cologne and perfume heralded the coming of the graduates. Nita sat between Laurence Herbert Grant, his winged collar and cravat complete with stickpin marking him as a bit old fashioned. He would move up to Fort Bragg and join the clergy. He looks a serious young man with his earnest expression, his thick wavy hair ruffling in the breeze. On her other side, Sydney Baldwin Gray, She of the small round glasses. She has the competent straight forward look of a teacher which she went on to be. Next in line, Ruth Van Kampen Green, married right after graduation. Her husband worked for United Fruit as a packer and she ultimately bore him eight children and spent a good deal of her life in Mexico and Brazil. They followed the banana trade. Next to Ruth was Edith Montgomery Grey who became a third grade teacher at Oak Park primary school in Folsom California. She resigned in 1920 in order to marry. Expectations were such that women should not have a career other than be a homemaker. She died soon after childbirth in 1920
A large majority of the women became teachers. Superbly educated, graduates of Cal were a hot commodity. California was growing rapidly and desperately needed more educators. Just as today, they found their way to the Normal School, Santa Barbara College , todays UCSB where they took a course of study to prep for the state teachers qualifying exam. These women were not the one room schoolhouse teachers of popular fiction. The California State Teachers exam of 1910 was brutal and was the equal of modern teachers requirements. Just as today, it took a five year course of study to qualify for a credential.
The college of Social Sciences at Berkeley, Nita’s school, was the largest at Cal in 1908, numbering over one thousand students. A student was promised a first class education just as they are today. She was required to have taken Latin at Santa Maria High School though Cal did not insist on Greek for the College of Social Sciences. She had a wide choice of classes in humanistic studies. She could choose classes in the great field of literature, linguistics, history and economics. Geography and education were also requirements and from the list of women graduates it can be seen that the most likely career was education.
Her curriculum shatters the old saw about the schoolmarm and the one room schoolhouse. One of the orphan girls Nita was raised with who was also schooled by uncle Patrick Moore, Mamie Tyler took her degree at a school founded as a private institution, ‘Minns’ Evening Normal School founded in 1857. That school became a public institution by act of the State Legislature on May 2, 1862. In 1868 the board of trustees took up the matter of permanent location, and Washington Square in San Jose was chosen. Mamie graduated in 1900 and taught much of her career in a log cabin near Port Angeles, Washington State.
Martha “Mamie” Tyler Kolloch and her students at the log cabin school in the Olympic forest Washington State, 1921 Shannon Family Photo
The first in California was originally founded as a private institution, ‘Minns’ Evening Normal School,’ in 1857, the school became a public institution by act of the State Legislature on May 2, 1862. In 1868 the board of trustees took up the matter of permanent location, and Washington Square in San Jose was chosen. San Jose State Teachers College was born. The Normal Schools were changed to state colleges in 1935 which allowed them to offer degrees in subjects other than education. Those schools make up the majority of the original California State Colleges including UCLA, San Diego State, UCSB and San Jose.
Normal Schools derive their name from the French phrase ecole normale. These teacher-training institutions, the first of which was established in France by the Brothers of the Christian Schools in 1685, were intended to set a pattern, establish a “norm” after which all other schools would be modeled, a pattern which has remained in effect until the present day.
Wether Nita’s goal was to teach we don’t know but many of the girls sponsored by Patrick Moore did become teachers. Education was important to the Moore’s and Nita’s parents, the Grays. Her entire extended family was made up of Irish immigrants for which education was the most cherished goal. A goal still shared by immigrants from all over the world.
Nita’s parents, her siblings, and friends had arrived in Oakland by train from home and waited anxiously in the tiered seats around the Theatre where the folding chairs awaited the arrival of the dignitaries and expectant graduates.
Baccalaureate, also in the Greek had been on Sunday in which Bishop Nichols sermon had emphasized the opportunity for “Men” of character and worth to make their stamp on the great state of California. No mention of women in 1908.
Class day on Monday saw seniors meeting at Senior Oak. A speech by class president Hartley followed by the progression of “Plugs and Parasols” which wound through the campus where they halted for speeches by fellow classmates who spoke on subjects they were most interested. Hardly anyone listened of course. Excitement was building to a fever pitch. Tuesday afternoon they sat for the final Symphony Concert of the year. Finally the last senior assembly in Harmon Gymnasium on Tuesday evening. Parasols were folded and Nita and her roommates went home a tried to get some sleep. Wednesday would be an early start. Gowns to be pressed, hair done up, shoes polished and then the process of dressing, the girls helping each other, pushing pulling and primping making everything “Just so.”
Wednesday, the graduates to be met and organized themselves for the procession up to the Greek. Waiting for the ceremony to begin was almost more than they could stand. Nervous chatter rose above the crowd, the occasional group of boys hooped and hollered to let of steam but finally, lined up in proper order they stepped out to the sound of the University Band and began to walk.
At the Greek they filed into the rows of chairs, carefully arranged in alphabetical order. The murmur of the crowd was underplayed by the chairs creaking as the soon to be graduates took their seats. The rise and fall of low voices marked the expectant crowd. For many this ceremony would be one of the highlights of their lives.
After the always interminable speeches, after four years of University life, Nita rose and joined the parade up the steps onto the stage at the Greek Theatre and received her diploma from the hand of President Benjamin Wheeler himself. Then polite congratulations from Mrs Hearst and the other regents and with that her book of education closed.
The “S” curve is still the mode for women in 1908 and the cut of Nita’s clothes emphasize that. Shannon Family Photo
And here’s to the ‘Naught eight co-eds, Our prettiest, sweetest and best.
Whose eyes laugh back with our laughter, Whose hearts glow warm with our zest.
To the girls who were women at entrance, But who will be girls ’til they die.
A toast! For we know they are loyal.
A toast! With our glasses held high.
For a final deep pledge to our class, boys
O a fig would we care for fate!
In the same old way we would drink to our class,
In a toast to old “Naught-eight.
From the Blue and Gold Yearbook, University of California Berkeley class of 1908 by Sheldon Chaney, ’08
Coming next: Nita, the third. Senior trip to Yosemite Valley.
Please Like and Follow.
Many thanks to my researcher Shirley Bennet Gibson from another old time local family. Couldn’t do it without her.
Michael Shannon is a surfer, traveler, teacher and writer.
She was a woman of sturdy shoes when I knew her. I cannot remember her without her apron, a sensible utilitarian piece of apparel worn by women of the early twentieth century to protect their clothes, a leftover from the days when, if you weren’t wealthy enough to have a laundress, you washed and ironed your own garments.
My grandmother was 60 years old when I was born. By the time I was old enough to know her she was well into her seventies. We never, ever talked about her life. Like many people she must have though it wasn’t very interesting which is how it must have looked from inside her head. The only things she ever shared with me came when she was in her nineties. I would sit on her sofa, the one with the pink roses pattern and from the space where she had retreated at the end of her life she would, with enough prompting, dispense snippets of it.
How the hired girl got “Knocked Up,” how uncle Pat would have to spend the night in the barn when he came home three sheets to the wind after a night at Ryan’s bar with his friends Daniel Rice and Patrick Donovan. The most interesting thing wasn’t that these things happened, both are pretty common in the human experience but for her use of the phrase which she would have consider extremely vulgar in her younger days or the story about Patrick Moore drinking which was something she had also disapproved off. She had reason to.
So I sat there with her, she in her bathrobe, something which would have horrified her when she was younger, she basking in the sun coming through the big picture window overlooking the places she had lived nearly all her life. Being ninety is being cold and the afternoon heat nearly put her to sleep, perhaps her guard was down.
When she was younger, every morning she would get up, start breakfast and then retire to her bedroom to complete her Toilette. Carefully combing her hair with the silver plated boars bristle brushes she had used since she was a girl, dusting herself lightly with White Shoulders and applying just a kiss of rouge to her lips with the tip of her Pinky. Girls who grew up at the end of the nineteenth century used almost no makeup; that would have been seen as vulgar in her circle. She had never changed.
Holding her little hand, the skin velvety soft and nearly translucent, having seldom ever seen the sun during her nine plus decades, for her complexion was her treasure. I cannot recall her ever going anywhere without gloves, long sleeves and a hat. Now she sat wrapped in her old pink terrycloth robe with the little embroidered roses on the collar, me listening carefully and giving her the a little spoken nudge to keep her talking, fascinated by what she told me.
My life was as different from hers as if I’d lived on the moon. Though we weren’t considered poor, the family had come down some financially since my grandmother was a girl. Families grow and money has to go farther. She was born to a moderately wealthy farming and ranching family from the Santa Maria area of California. Midwife delivered in a little house just off Division road and the old coast highway in Oso Flaco. She was the second of seven children of Irish immigrants Samuel and Jeannie Gray. Sam Gray and Jennie McKeen were married on May 12th, 1881 at the Orange Hall in Bailie Riobaird Doagh, county Antrim. They traveled to Belfast and boarded the States Line ship, SS State of Alabama and sailed to America on their honeymoon. Boarding at Belfast, they came ashore at Manhattan’s Castle Gardens. The State of Alabama was no Coffin ship like the vessels that delivered the first wave of famine Irish forty years earlier but she was no cruise ship either. Sam and his bride traveled third class, just a step above steerage. They never returned to Kilbride Parish, Upper Antrim, County Antrim, ever again. Like most Irish immigrants the family left behind was forever lost.
Like many they made the long hop across the country to California very quickly. Immigrant families followed a chain of family migration as they still do. Jeannie Gray’s Aunt Sarah, married to Patrick Moore of Cavan, Ireland, todays Cork, had come to America in 1850 when he was just 18. He moved west to Ohio from New York, became a naturalized citizen in 1868 and by Annies birth was living with his extended family in the Guadalupe and the Arroyo Grande Areas of central California.
The Moores by the eighties were a wealthy family, Patrick being what he called a capitalist had acquired thousands of acres of the old Mexican Land Grant Rancho’s. He had also invested in the nascent Oil business in Casmalia and the Orcutt area. He was a principle of the Pinal Oil Company and by the turn of the century had become not only a land owner but a private banker. Banks of the sort we are familiar with today didn’t exist then and most loans were made with a handshake. Uncle Pat was good at his work and scrupulously honest.
Pat and Sarah Moore had only one great sadness in their lives, they were childless and they loved children. Because Jennie Gray was Sarah Moore’s niece and by 1895 had seven living children, the Moore’s proposed that little Annie Gray, the second child come to live with them in Arroyo Grande. After some discussion a deal was worked out whereas the Moore’s would feed and cloth her, pay for her education at the California University at Berkeley, and upon passing, deed her a Quarter section of land and gift her a number of shares in the oil company. The custom of “Loaning” children out to relatives isn’t common anymore but was not unusual for the time.
In 1893 Annie came to live with the Moores. In the big house. On the Hill. She had, for the first time her own room on the second floor and servants to take care of her needs, It was quite a change. In the picture above, the two older girls on the left are the Tyler sisters. They lived with the Moore’s also. Their parents had both died within a year of each other and Sarah and Pat took it upon themselves to raise them too. It was always said by those who knew that the big house was always filled with the children of the town.
As Annie grew, these many friends shared their lives together as children and teenagers. The Kodak Box camera was invented just in time to chronicle much of their lives growing up. Annie was fifteen when the camera came on the market and we have albums of photos taken with what must have been, a marvelous new thing. They took pictures the way girls use their I-Phones today.
They chronicled all kinds of events, birthday parties, holidays or even any excuse to get together. Arroyo Grande was such a small town that you could walk across it in just a few minutes and like little places, everyone, they knew each other. One hundred and twenty years later most of the family names in her autograph books still reside here including my future grandfather whose beautiful copperplate signature is scattered throughout the pages of that little book.
As promised, Annie was off to Berkeley in 1904. She graduated from Santa Maria High School in 1904 in the same class with her oldest brother Robert Gray. Though she lived in Arroyo Grande with the Moore’s she would spend the week with her parents on their ranch on Guadalupe road, taking the narrow gauge railroad down on Monday morning and returning for the weekend. The high school in Arroyo Grande was not accredited for the university. It had a somewhat sketchy history and had ceased to exist for a few years as a group of wealthy ranchers refused to pay taxes to support a high school, deeming it an unnecessary level of education. “Boys need to go to work, not school, and girls need to marry and keep house,” said Harold Miossi. one of the ringleaders in the anti-school delegation. Daniel Donovan, big landowner and friend of Pat Moore was leader in defunding the school. The conversations between these and the other town leaders in the bar at the Ryan Hotel on Branch Street must have been interesting. According to family lore, uncle Pat and his crony’s could put it away in vast quantities and the arguments were detailed in the local papers. My grandfather Jack Shannon and his friends including “Ace” Porter, George Clevenger and Frank Bardin all ended their formal education at eighth grade. They all prospered in spite of going to do a grownups work at fourteen.
Pat and Sarah Moore were decidedly against the no-school crowd and not only sent Annie of to college but paid for the schooling of several of her friends including the girl below pictured in her high school graduation picture. She returned to Arroyo Grande and taught school. She was so well liked that a grammar school was named for her. She was my grandmother good friend and spent many hours in the big house just up the hill from her own next to Pig Tail Alley on old Bridge Street..
Margaret Phoenix Harloe. 1901. HS graduation photo.
Berkeley was a far different school in 1904 than it is today. Girls had only a limited series of choices in which to study and like my grandmother, most would graduate with a Baccalaureate degree in Liberal Arts. There were few careers open to educated woman. The School of Architecture was founded only in 1903 by an endowment from Phoebe Apperson Hearst who was already championing women’s education, particularly women in Architecture. Mrs Hearst was a supporter of Julia Morgan, famously the architect of Hearst Castle. Morgan, herself was a woman of many firsts. She was one of the very first female graduates of the Engineering School at Berkeley and the very first woman to graduate from the prestigious French Ecole Nacionale Superiuere des Beaux-Artes. She was also the first licensed woman architect in California in 1903. In Annies sophomore year, The world famous Bancroft Library was added to the Universities collection that year and in 1905, Elizabeth Josselyn Boalt endowed the school with funds to build a permanent building for the School of Jurisprudence.
The famous “Big C” was built in march of 1905, Annies 2nd year at Cal. Her classmates of ’07 and ’08 formed a human chain to haul the blocks of sandstone uphill in a heavy rain. The “C” represents the peaceful end of the Charter Hill Rush held between the freshman and sophomores. It is a symbol of peace and unity. The Sophs were in charge of keeping it in good repair and each year, “The Deed to the C” was transferred to the next years sophomore class in a ceremony each spring.
The “Big C” was and is considered legitimate game for opponents of California Athletics, particularly the private school boys of Stanford. Each year before the Cal/Stanford football game it is lit and guarded through the night by members of the Sophomore class.
During the time Annie was a Cal there were no dorms or sororities for women. Girls boarded in homes around campus and she was no exception. She had a room in the home of Doctor Arvan Meeks and his wife Minna, a well-to-do dentist practicing in Berkeley. He and his wife took in a number of boarders from the school each year.
As young girls still do, she chose her nickname or it was chosen for her by friends. Why Nita, no one ever said but she carried it from early girlhood until she finished at the University. A short name or nickname is a sign of intimacy, trust, and friendship. We see Nita in her autograph book which dates back to the 1890’s and even in a letter written to her by her friend Mamie, another nickname, from her old folks home in Washington state when they were both in their early nineties. It had staying power. Likely because they were childhood friends and raised together they never called each other anything else. Nita is a diminutive for Anita or Ana if you speak Spanish. It could have been either one or as is sometimes the case just a way to distance themselves from names they didn’t themselves choose. I never heard anyone call her anything but Annie, not Anne or Anita. Annie was her given name. Perhaps they though Annie was too much like a servants name or something she would say all of her life; “Thats Shanty Irish”, styling herself as the Lace Curtain kind. They were raised in style.
Whatever the reason it set the tone for the early part of her life. Born to a wealthy first generation Irish family, raised by a rich first generation Irish family. A good start.