Letters to my Sons
Michael Shannon.
One thing about the old west was that the difference between good law and bad law was that there was no distance. Examples abound to illustrate that law and order were simply opposites of the same coin.
Bill Hickok was a killer no matter which side he was on and sometimes he was both at the same time. Wyatt Earp and his brothers were lawmen except when they weren’t. They somehow managed to pimp prostitutes which sometime were their wives and sit at Faro tables and cheat the odd cowpoke or hard rock miner out of their pay. Extortion bullying, and violence were their stock in trade. As the citizens of Tombstone were wont to say, the sooner they leave the better.
Good press and movies can also write history. The reality, if you choose wisely is much different. You can dress them in fur coats but a gun thug is still a gun thug.
Billy Bonney, renowned killer lived in Lincoln County and murdered 21 men befor he turned twenty one. Official records recorded only four between 1870 and 1900. No screenwriter wants to hear that do they?
In the legendary Cow Towns of Kansas like Abilene, Dodge City, Ellsworth, Wichita, and Caldwell over a 15-year span from 1870 to 1885, researchers have documented a total of only 45 killings.
In the TV series Yellowstone, Taylor Sheridan and his writers have killed many more than that. Every episode is a blood bath.
The Bandidos of Old California were in the end very bad men and to characterize them as Robin Hoods isn’t credible. What is credible is that they were a consequence of the literal invasion by a horde of whites from the east. In a short span of a decade 1848 to 1858 California’s population grew from roughly 7,000 to 350,000 overwhelming the classical Ranchero life into a white immigrant one. It’s estimated that the native population in 1848 was somewhere around 150,00 but by the 1850s had been reduced to about 24,000.
A person can argue all day how it was not the invasion, but that flys in the face of that is that until 1872 the year before Dad Shannon arrived in California it was the official policy of the state government as written in law explicitly banned certain racial groups from testifying in court cases involving white individuals. Ruled legal by the states Supreme Court in 1854 it stated in Section 394 of the Civil Practice Act: “No Indian or Negro shall be allowed to testify as a witness in any action in which a White person is a party.”Section 14 of the Criminal Act (1850) stated: “No Black, or Mulatto, Mestizo, or person of mixed blood, or an Indian shall be allowed to give evidence in favor of, or against a White man.”
Chief Justice Hugh Murray argued that terms like “Indian” and “Black” were generic categories meant to contrast against “White,” thereby legally barring all non-white individuals—including Chinese and other Asian immigrants—from testifying against white people in a court of law.
Did miners repeatedly rape and then murder Jaoquin Murietta’s wife? No one really knows but is an example of what white men were responsible and capable of in the early history of California. Did George Hall and his brother jump the claim of the Chinese man, Ling Sing by shooting and killing him? There was no doubt according to credible witness’s that Hall was a murderer and his was sentenced to hang by the local judge.
Enter Chief Justice Murray who wrote in the appeal that it would be “most anomalous” and absurd to think that California law would not protect white people from the “degraded and demoralized” castes of all non-white people, including Chinese people. Allowing non-white people to testify against a white man would be dangerous, Justice Murray wrote. If they were allowed to testify, they might then be allowed to become citizens and jurors and legislators. That was not mere speculation, he wrote, but “an actual and present danger.” Still sounds familiar 172 years later.
Tiburcio was just 17 years old when this case unfolded. He was by all rights the “Wild Child” of an old California family dating back to 1797. His great-grandfather was a soldado with the Spanish De Anza exploration of California and for his service was awarded a massive Rancho by the King of Spain. The Vasquez family was comfortably middle class and Tiburcio was well educated in the mission schools and could both speak and write english.
Sadly by the time Dad shannon joined the Sheriffs Deptartment, he was only twenty five at the time, the 49ers and other Boomers had practically erased the old Californio culture, taking land by fiat and by controlling the courts. Grasping with both hands is the nature of some humans and they were in full swing. The old Ranchos which were limited in size by the King of Spain and then Mexican rule in order to control the state of Alta California and maintain control over local politics was out the window. By 1875 Heinrich Kreiser or Henry Miller and his partner Alfred Lux owned over 300,000 acres of California land outright. Over ten times more tha the largest Ranchos. They also cleverly utilized strategic water rights and grazing leases to control millions of additional acres across the San Joaquin Valley and surrounding regions. At the peak of their empire, Miller & Lux owned 1.4 million acres outright and controlled over 22,000 square miles across California, Nevada, and Oregon. It was famously said that Miller could ride from Mexico to Canada while sleeping on his own land every night.
Murietta, Tiburcio Vasquez. Salomon Pico the famous Californio bandidos expressed the feelings of many of their contemporaries who had been too young to enjoy the heyday of the ranchos.
Their abilities as vaqueros and horsemen – so prized and necessary during the rancho era – were no longer a source of prestige. And few opportunities for acquiring wealth and status were available to them. Either sell their skills for relatively low pay as vaqueros or ranch hands or try and learn another manual trade. For a man whose self esteem required him to mount his horse and ride across the street rather than walking it was devestating.

Vaqueros, prideful in their dress, manners and status. Stanley Walter Galli . 1976
Tiburcio said,”As I grew to manhood I was in the habit of attending balls and parties given by the native Californians, into which the Americans, then beginning to become numerous, would force themselves and shove the native born men aside, monopolizing the dance and the women.
Vásquez became a protégé of Anastacio García, one of California’s most dangerous bandits. In 1854, Vásquez was present at the slaying of Monterey Constable William Hardmount, during a fight with García at a fandango in Monterey. Vásquez denied any involvement in the murder. Still he ran. It changed his life.
Vásquez had chosen another route, one where his skills as a horseman served him well. For two decades he roamed California as a cattle rustler and a bandido, gaining notoriety among Anglo-Americans and popularity among Mexican Californians. His fame and prestige increased with every successful robbery and his life became fuel for legends and tall tales.
When Dad Shannon signed on as a deputy, the Sheriff, already known as the “Bloodhound of the west,” for his successful arrest of a number of Californio Bandidos had captured several famous outlaws including Juan Soto, Bartolo Sepulveda, and “Red-Handed” Procopio. He later worked alongside an, associate James Hume to identify Charles E. Boles the “Gentleman Bandit, Black Bart.”
In 1874 Sheriff Morse set his sights on Vasquez. The Governor, Newton Booth had just set a bounty on Vasquez head, $8,000 alive, $6,000 for a* corpse. Organizing a posse which included Dad Shannon he set out on what would be a twelve hundred mile chase through northern and central California.
Morse and his men set off. They took the Southern Pacific railroad down the coast route from Alameda. Southern Pacific operated one daily round-trip passenger and freight train along this Soledad branch, taking about 6 hours and 45 minutes for a one-way run. Detraining at San Juan Bautista they spent the first day nosing around the saloons, cafes and boarding houses looking for information on Vasquez’ whereabouts.
The next morning they rented horses and set out on what they hoped was his trail.
Next: Dad Shannon, saddle sores.
Michael Shannon is the grandson of John Edward “Dad” Shannon. n a family’s life a good story has to be told.




















